- 2068 Baishakh (old course) · 4 marks
Knowledge without wisdom makes education futile
Short answer
Knowledge without wisdom gives power without moral direction, risking misuse. Education must balance ability with wise judgment to create a better society.
'Mere knowledge without wisdom makes education futile'. Justify this. (Knowledge and Wisdom)
Russell holds in "Knowledge and Wisdom" that education which gives only information and skill, without wisdom, is not enough and can even be harmful. The statement is justified for the following reasons.
- Knowledge is a power, not a guide. Knowledge tells us how to do things, but wisdom tells us what is worth doing. Without wisdom the power can be used wrongly, as in the making of destructive weapons.
- Narrow specialisation. Education that trains only experts makes people see one small part of life. They may ignore the effects of their work on society.
- Lack of moral purpose. Knowledge alone does not produce compassion, impartiality or a sense of proportion. A highly educated person may still be selfish, hateful or fanatical.
- Danger to humanity. In the modern world, scientific knowledge has increased faster than wisdom, so that the human race faces dangers it cannot control.
- Does not make good citizens. A nation needs people who can judge public matters fairly. Technical education alone does not teach this.
- Wisdom completes education. True education should develop both: knowledge for ability and wisdom for right use.
Therefore education that gives knowledge without wisdom fails in its main purpose, which is to make better human beings and a better society.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Knowledge and Wisdom: sense of proportion · Communication English, chapter 2 · asked 2×
- Russell: wisdom more necessary with knowledge · Communication English, chapter 2 · asked 2×
- Difference between knowledge and wisdom · Communication English, chapter 2
- Interpret: wisdom and emancipation (Russell) · Communication English, chapter 1
- Features contributing to wisdom · Communication English, chapter 2
- Difference between impartiality and wisdom · Communication English, chapter 2
- True/false: feedback makes response faster · Control Systems, chapter 1
- True/false: proportional controller makes error zero · Control Systems, chapter 7