Skip to main content

True/false: proportional controller makes error zero

Short answer

False. A proportional controller only reduces steady-state error; it cannot make it zero unless the plant already contains an integrator. Zero error requires integral action, which adds a pole at the origin.

State whether the following statement is true or false and justify: Proportional controller makes the steady state error zero.

False. A proportional controller only reduces the steady-state error; it cannot make it zero (unless the plant already contains an integrator).

Justification. With Gc(s)=KpG_c(s) = K_p and a type-0 plant G(s)G(s) in a unity feedback loop, the step error is

ess=lim⁡s→0s⋅1s1+KpG(s)=11+KpG(0)e_{ss} = \lim_{s\to 0} \frac{s\cdot\frac{1}{s}}{1 + K_p G(s)} = \frac{1}{1 + K_p G(0)}

Example: G(s)=1s+1G(s) = \dfrac{1}{s+1}, so G(0)=1G(0) = 1.

KpK_pess=1/(1+Kp)e_{ss} = 1/(1+K_p)
10.5
90.1
990.01

The error falls as KpK_p rises but becomes zero only for Kp→∞K_p \to \infty, which is not possible. Very high gain also makes higher-order systems oscillatory or unstable and saturates the actuator.

A P controller adds no pole at the origin, so it does not change the system type. Zero steady-state error needs integral action (PI or PID controller), which adds a pole at s=0s = 0.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 7 questions →