- 2066 Chaitra (old course) · 3+2 marks
Why well-graded aggregate is better
Short answer
A well-graded aggregate packs densely, minimises voids and paste demand, improving workability, strength, and durability while cutting shrinkage and permeability. It is identified by a grading curve lying smoothly within IS 383 limits, a high uniformity coefficient (C_u>4–6), and a curvature coefficient (C_c) between1 and3.
How is well-graded aggregate better than others? On which basis can you say that an aggregate is well graded? Explain.
A well-graded aggregate has particles of all sizes from large to small, in proportions that fill the voids.
Why it is better
- Minimum voids: small particles fill the gaps between large ones, so the paste required is less and cement is saved.
- Better workability with lower water: reduces segregation and bleeding.
- Higher density and strength for the same cement content and lower permeability, so better durability.
- Less shrinkage and creep (less paste).
- Uniform, cohesive mixes without honeycombing; easier compaction and finishing.
- Compared with single-size (many voids, high paste demand) and gap-graded (risk of segregation) aggregates, well graded gives the most economical mix.
Basis for judging well graded
- Sieve analysis (IS 2386 Part 1): the percentage passing each IS sieve should lie within the IS 383 limits (Table 7 for coarse aggregate, Table 9 for fine zones I-IV).
- The grading curve is smooth and continuous with no flat steps.
- Fineness modulus within the required range (e.g. 2.6-3.0 for medium sand; all-in 3.5-6.5).
- Coefficients: uniformity coefficient (large, above 4-6 for well-graded) and curvature coefficient between 1 and 3.
- Practical check: lowest void content (loose/rodded bulk density test) among combinations.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Aggregate size; well-graded from grading curve · Concrete Technology and Masonry Structure, chapter 1
- Gap-graded aggregate and role of grading · Concrete Technology and Masonry Structure, chapter 1
- Preventive maintenance is better than corrective · Construction Management, chapter 9 · asked 4×
- Why Kaiser window is better than fixed windows · Digital Signal Analysis and Processing, chapter 5 · asked 2×
- Closed loop better than open loop (cruise) · Embedded System, chapter 7
- When wet process is better than dry · Civil Engineering Materials, chapter 5
All Concrete Technology and Masonry Structure chapter 1 questions →