Skip to main content

Average rainfall methods with merits and demerits

Short answer

Arithmetic mean is simplest but ignores spatial variation. Thiessen polygon weights gauges by area and is objective, but ignores orography. Isohyetal method is most accurate as it incorporates topography and storm pattern, but requires dense gauges and skilled plotting.

Explain the different methods of determining the average rainfall over a catchment due to a storm. Discuss the relative merits and demerits of the various methods.

Rain gauges give point rainfall. The mean rainfall over a catchment due to a storm is found by three methods.

1. Arithmetic mean method

Pˉ=P1+P2+⋯+Pnn\bar P = \frac{P_1+P_2+\dots+P_n}{n}

The simple average of the gauges inside the catchment. Used for flat areas with uniformly spread gauges and rainfall that varies little.

2. Thiessen polygon method

  1. Plot the gauges on the catchment map and join adjacent gauges to form triangles.
  2. Draw perpendicular bisectors of the sides; they form a polygon around each gauge.
  3. Measure the area AiA_i of each polygon inside the catchment.
  4. Compute
Pˉ=∑AiPi∑Ai\bar P = \frac{\sum A_i P_i}{\sum A_i}

3. Isohyetal method

  1. Draw isohyets (lines of equal rainfall) by interpolating between gauge values.
  2. Find the area AiA_i between consecutive isohyets and the mean of their values Pˉi\bar P_i.
  3. Compute Pˉ=∑AiPˉi/∑Ai\bar P = \sum A_i \bar P_i / \sum A_i.

Merits and demerits

MethodMeritsDemerits
Arithmetic meanVery simple, quick, needs no mapIgnores gauge position and relief; poor for uneven gauges or storms
Thiessen polygonWeights gauges by area; objective; good for moderately uneven gauge spreadIgnores orography; polygons must be redrawn when a gauge is added or missing; assumes rainfall is the same over the polygon
IsohyetalMost accurate; includes relief and storm pattern; gives rainfall patternNeeds a dense network and skill; more time; subjective drawing of isohyets

For hilly catchments such as those in Nepal, the isohyetal method is preferred if enough gauges exist; otherwise Thiessen is used.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Engineering Hydrology chapter 2 questions →