Skip to main content

Max height of unsupported clay excavation

Short answer

For a vertical cut in clay (φ=0) at active state, total thrust Pa = ½γHc² − 2cHc. Setting Pa=0 yields maximum unsupported height Hc = 4c/γ (or 4cu/γ) before cracking. With tension cracks and safety factor, practical height is smaller.

Derive a relation for the maximum height of unsupported excavation in clayey soil.

For a vertical cut in clay with ϕ=0\phi = 0, cohesion cc and unit weight γ\gamma, Rankine's active pressure at depth zz is

pa=γz−2cp_a = \gamma z - 2c

since Ka=1K_a = 1. The pressure is zero at z0=2c/γz_0 = 2c/\gamma and tensile above it.

For an unsupported (vertical) cut, the soil is stable up to the height at which the total active thrust over the full height is zero; i.e. the compressive force below balances the tension above, so no support is needed:

Pa=∫0Hc(γz−2c) dz=12γHc2−2cHc=0Hc=4cγ\begin{aligned} P_a &= \int_0^{H_c}(\gamma z - 2c)\,dz = \tfrac12\gamma H_c^2 - 2cH_c = 0 \\ H_c &= \frac{4c}{\gamma} \end{aligned}

Result: Hc=4c/γH_c = 4c/\gamma (for c=cuc = c_u in undrained condition, Hc=4cu/γH_c = 4c_u/\gamma). Using a factor of safety, the safe height is H=Hc/FH = H_c/F.

Note: because soil cannot carry tension, tension cracks of depth 2c/γ2c/\gamma form; considering them, the practical safe height is smaller (the theoretical value with the cracks is 2.67c/γ2.67c/\gamma by Terzaghi's analysis), so a factor of safety of 2 or more is used.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Foundation Engineering chapter 3 questions →