- Asked 4/11
- 2073 Shrawan · 5 marks
- 2072 Chaitra · 5 marks
- 2071 Shrawan · 6 marks
- 2071 Chaitra · 3 marks
- Year not given
Compare OSI and TCP/IP models
Short answer
OSI is a seven-layer protocol-independent reference model from ISO; TCP/IP is a four-layer practical model from the US DoD built around Internet protocols. OSI separates session/presentation and data link/physical layers, while TCP/IP merges them. TCP/IP is the actual Internet standard; OSI is mainly for teaching and reference.
Differentiate between the OSI and TCP/IP reference models.
The OSI model is a seven-layer, protocol-independent reference model from ISO, while the TCP/IP model is a four-layer (sometimes five-layer) practical model built around the protocols of the Internet.
OSI TCP/IP
+--------------+
| Application |
| Presentation | +-------------+
| Session | | Application |
+--------------+ +-------------+
| Transport | | Transport |
+--------------+ +-------------+
| Network | | Internet |
+--------------+ +-------------+
| Data link | | Host-to- |
| Physical | | network |
+--------------+ +-------------+
| Point | OSI model | TCP/IP model |
|---|---|---|
| Layers | 7 | 4 (Application, Transport, Internet, Host-to-network) |
| Developed by | ISO | US DoD (ARPANET) |
| Approach | Model first, protocols later | Protocols first, model later |
| Session and presentation | Separate layers | Merged into application layer |
| Data link and physical | Separate layers | Merged into host-to-network layer |
| Service, interface, protocol | Clearly separated concepts | Not clearly separated |
| Transport layer | Connection-oriented only (reliable) | Both: TCP (reliable, connection-oriented) and UDP (unreliable, connectionless) |
| Network layer | Both connection-oriented and connectionless | Connectionless only (IP) |
| Protocol fit | Protocols are better hidden and easier to replace | Not generic; cannot describe non-TCP/IP stacks well |
| Use | Teaching and reference | Actual Internet standard |
Similarities: both are layered, both have application, transport and network-type layers, and both use packet switching.
Main reason TCP/IP won: its protocols already worked and were free, while OSI was complex, late and badly timed.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Explain OSI model and its layers · Computer Networks and Security, chapter 1 · asked 2×
- Tasks done at OSI layers (set 2) · Computer Networks and Security, chapter 1
- Functions of physical layer · Computer Networks and Security, chapter 2
- Why two transport protocols exist · Computer Networks and Security, chapter 5
- TCP/IP applications; IPv4 vs IPv6 routing · Internet and Intranet, chapter 2
- Compare software models; propose a fourth model · Instrumentation II, chapter 9
- Compare RGB, CMY and HSB models · Multimedia System, chapter 3
- SS7 vs OSI; MTP-L2 signal units · Telecommunications, chapter 5