Skip to main content

Similitude and scale model of a bracket

Short answer

Similitude allows model-to-prototype prediction when geometric (length ratio λ), kinematic (similar motions) and dynamic (similar force ratios) similarity hold. For the 1:4 steel cantilever, using stress ∝ F/L² and deflection ∝ F/L: prototype load for equal stress is 32 kN, tip deflection 4.8 mm, stress under 2 kN is 4.69 MPa.

(a) What is similitude? Explain geometric, kinematic and dynamic similarity. (b) A geometrically similar 1:4 scale model (model = 1/4 of prototype) of a steel cantilever bracket, made of the same steel, is loaded at its tip with 2 kN. It shows a maximum bending stress of 75 MPa and a tip deflection of 1.2 mm. Find the tip load on the prototype that gives the same maximum stress, the prototype tip deflection, and the stress in the prototype if it is loaded with the same 2 kN.

(a) Similitude

Similitude is the set of conditions under which results measured on a model can be used to predict the behaviour of the full-size prototype.

  • Geometric similarity: all linear dimensions have the same ratio λ=Lp/Lm\lambda = L_p/L_m, and angles are equal.
  • Kinematic similarity: motions are similar; velocities at corresponding points have the same ratio and direction.
  • Dynamic similarity: forces at corresponding points have the same ratio (for example equal Reynolds, Froude or Mach number); this includes similar load and stress patterns in solids.

(b) Numerical

Scale ratio λ=Lp/Lm=4\lambda = L_p/L_m = 4. Same material, so EE is the same.

Bending stress at the root: σ=McI∝FL⋅LL4=FL2\sigma = \dfrac{M c}{I} \propto \dfrac{F L \cdot L}{L^4} = \dfrac{F}{L^2}.

Tip deflection: δ=FL33EI∝FL3L4=FL\delta = \dfrac{F L^3}{3EI} \propto \dfrac{F L^3}{L^4} = \dfrac{F}{L} (E constant).

1. Prototype load for equal stress

FpFm=λ2=16Fp=16×2=32 kN\begin{aligned} \frac{F_p}{F_m} &= \lambda^2 = 16 \\ F_p &= 16 \times 2 = 32\ \text{kN} \end{aligned}

2. Prototype deflection

δpδm=Fp/Fmλ=164=4δp=4×1.2=4.8 mm\begin{aligned} \frac{\delta_p}{\delta_m} &= \frac{F_p/F_m}{\lambda} = \frac{16}{4} = 4 \\ \delta_p &= 4 \times 1.2 = 4.8\ \text{mm} \end{aligned}

(Deflection scales with λ\lambda, as in geometric similarity at equal stress.)

3. Stress when the prototype carries only 2 kN

σp=σm×FpFm×1λ2=75×116=4.69 MPa\sigma_p = \sigma_m \times \frac{F_p}{F_m}\times\frac{1}{\lambda^2} = 75 \times \frac{1}{16} = 4.69\ \text{MPa}

Answer: prototype load = 32 kN, prototype tip deflection = 4.8 mm, stress under 2 kN = 4.69 MPa.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Machine Design II chapter 1 questions →