Which is the correct order for setting project goals?

Identify need and stakeholders, state broad goal, break into objectives, test against SMART, get client approval

State SMART objectives first, then identify the need, then the broad goal

Get client approval first, then identify the need, then set objectives

Break into objectives, identify stakeholders, then state the broad goal without any testing

What do the letters in SMART stand for in goal setting?

Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic/Relevant, Time-bound

Simple, Monitored, Approved, Reported, Tested

Specific, Managed, Allocated, Reviewed, Timed

Strategic, Measured, Authorised, Required, Tracked

Why is 'Improve the road to the village' a poor objective while 'Construct a 12 km, 5.5 m wide black-topped road within 24 months at not more than NRs 40 crore' is SMART?

The first has no quantity, standard, cost or deadline, while the second gives length, width, cost, standard and time

The first is too expensive and the second is cheaper

The first is for a village and the second is for a city

The first has too many details and the second has fewer

In SMART, what does 'Achievable' check compared with 'Realistic'?

Achievable: possible with available resources and technology; Realistic: matches the need and the organisation's capacity

Achievable: has a deadline; Realistic: has a budget

Achievable: can be measured; Realistic: is clearly stated

Achievable: is approved by client; Realistic: is cheap

Asked 5/26
2072 Chaitra · 5 marks
2070 Chaitra · 5 marks
2070 Chaitra (old course) · 4 marks
2066 Bhadra (old course) · 4 marks
2068 Baisakh (old course) · 8 marks

Project goal setting and criteria (SMART)

Short answer

Project goals are set by identifying needs and stakeholders, then defining objectives that are Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, and Time-bound (SMART). For example, constructing a 12 km black-topped road within 24 months and NRs 40 crore budget.

How are project goals or objectives set? Explain the goal setting criteria (SMART) with the aid of a suitable example.

Goals and objectives are set by understanding the need or problem, consulting the stakeholders, and stating the end result in clear, measurable terms. The usual sequence is:

Identify the need or problem and the stakeholders.
State the broad goal (the long-term purpose).
Break the goal into specific objectives (short-term, measurable results).
Test each objective against the SMART criteria.
Get approval from the client and revise if resources or constraints do not match.

SMART criteria

Letter	Criterion	Meaning
S	Specific	Clear and unambiguous; says what, where and for whom
M	Measurable	Quantity, quality or cost can be checked
A	Achievable	Possible with available resources and technology
R	Realistic / Relevant	Matches the need and the organisation's capacity
T	Time-bound	Has a deadline or time frame

Example

Poor objective: "Improve the road to the village."

SMART objective: "Construct a 12 km, 5.5 m wide black-topped road from X to Y, within 24 months, at a cost not exceeding NRs 40 crore, meeting Department of Roads standards."

Specific: 12 km black-topped road from X to Y.
Measurable: length, width, cost and standard are given.
Achievable: the equipment, contractor and budget are available.
Realistic: the village needs year-round access.
Time-bound: 24 months.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

Project, characteristics and SMART goal setting · Project Engineering, chapter 1
Goal vs objective; goal setting criteria · Project Engineering, chapter 1
Life cycle phases and goal setting example · Project Engineering, chapter 1
Project family tree and goal criteria · Project Engineering, chapter 1
Goal versus objective of a project · Project Engineering, chapter 1
Needs, goals, constraints and criteria · Machine Design I, chapter 4

All Project Engineering chapter 1 questions →

Project goal setting and criteria (SMART)

SMART criteria

Example

Related questions