Skip to main content

Dynamic balancing with two correction planes

Short answer

Take plane L as reference; couple balance gives plane M mass 9.85 kg at 9.5° from A. Force balance then gives plane L mass 15.29 kg at 242.0° from A, both at 150 mm radius.

A shaft carries four masses A, B, C and D of 18 kg, 24 kg, 30 kg and 22 kg at radii 100 mm, 120 mm, 90 mm and 110 mm respectively, in parallel planes. Measured from plane A, the angular positions of B, C and D are 70∘70^\circ, 150∘150^\circ and 250∘250^\circ in the same sense. The planes of A, B, C and D are 0.20 m, 0.55 m, 0.95 m and 1.40 m from a balancing plane L, and a second balancing plane M is 1.70 m from L (on the same side as the other planes, beyond D). The balancing masses in L and M are to rotate at a radius of 150 mm. Find the magnitudes and angular positions of the balancing masses.

Method: Take plane L as the reference plane. For complete balance, ∑mr=0\sum mr = 0 (forces) and ∑mr x=0\sum mr\,x = 0 (couples). Use the angle of A as 0∘0^\circ. Unknowns: mLm_L, mMm_M and their angles.

Couple about plane L

Planemm (kg)rr (m)mrmrxx (m)mrxmrxθ\thetamrxcos⁡θmrx\cos\thetamrxsin⁡θmrx\sin\theta
A180.101.800.200.3600+0.3600.000
B240.122.880.551.58470+0.542+1.488
C300.092.700.952.565150-2.221+1.282
D220.112.421.403.388250-1.159-3.184
∑mrxcos⁡θ=−2.478,∑mrxsin⁡θ=−0.413  (kg⋅m2)\sum mrx\cos\theta = -2.478, \qquad \sum mrx\sin\theta = -0.413\ \ (\text{kg·m}^2)

The couple of the balancing mass in M about L must cancel this. Plane M is at xM=1.70x_M = 1.70 m, so

mMrMxM=(−2.478)2+(−0.413)2=2.512 kg⋅m2m_M r_M x_M = \sqrt{(-2.478)^2 + (-0.413)^2} = 2.512\ \text{kg·m}^2 mMrM=2.5121.70=1.478 kg⋅m⇒mM=1.4780.15=9.85 kgm_M r_M = \frac{2.512}{1.70} = 1.478\ \text{kg·m} \Rightarrow m_M = \frac{1.478}{0.15} = 9.85\ \text{kg}

The couple of mMm_M must point opposite to the resultant couple, i.e. along (+2.478, +0.413)(+2.478,\ +0.413):

θM=tan⁡−10.4132.478=9.5∘\theta_M = \tan^{-1}\frac{0.413}{2.478} = 9.5^\circ

Force balance

Planemrmr (kg·m)θ\thetamrcos⁡θmr\cos\thetamrsin⁡θmr\sin\theta
A1.800+1.8000.000
B2.8870+0.985+2.706
C2.70150-2.338+1.350
D2.42250-0.828-2.274
M1.4789.5+1.458+0.243

The four given masses give ∑H=−0.381\sum H = -0.381 and ∑V=1.782\sum V = 1.782 (kg·m). Adding plane M gives 1.0771.077 and 2.0252.025, so plane L must supply

mLrLcos⁡θL=−1.077,mLrLsin⁡θL=−2.025m_L r_L\cos\theta_L = -1.077, \qquad m_L r_L\sin\theta_L = -2.025 mLrL=(−1.077)2+(−2.025)2=2.294 kg⋅m⇒mL=2.2940.15=15.29 kgm_L r_L = \sqrt{(-1.077)^2 + (-2.025)^2} = 2.294\ \text{kg·m} \Rightarrow m_L = \frac{2.294}{0.15} = 15.29\ \text{kg}

Both components are negative, so the angle is in the third quadrant:

θL=180∘+tan⁡−12.0251.077=242.0∘\theta_L = 180^\circ + \tan^{-1}\frac{2.025}{1.077} = 242.0^\circ

Answer: Plane L: mL=15.29m_L = 15.29 kg at 242.0∘242.0^\circ from A. Plane M: mM=9.85m_M = 9.85 kg at 9.5∘9.5^\circ from A (both at 150 mm radius, same sense as the given angles).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Mechanism and Machine II chapter 5 questions →