Skip to main content

Most economical conductor, five options (Rs 9)

Short answer

The most economical conductor is Zebra, with a minimum total annual cost of Rs 516.58 thousand per km, computed as annual capital charge plus annual loss cost (energy lost times rate).

For transmission line design following computations has been made. Select the most economical conductor.

ConductorTotal tower cost/km (1000 Rs)Total conductor cost/km (1000 Rs)Annual energy loss/km (1000 kWh)
Goat890125432
Sheep936145027
Zebra974158524
Deer964166324
Elk968184721

Using the following data choose the best conductor: Energy rate = Rs. 9.0 per unit, Interest rate = 10%, Project life = 20 years.

The most economical conductor is the one with the minimum total annual cost per km: the annual charge on capital (towers plus conductor) plus the annual cost of energy lost (Kelvin's law idea).

Capital recovery factor

CRF=i(1+i)n(1+i)n−1=0.1(1.1)20(1.1)20−1=0.1×6.72755.7275=0.11746CRF = \frac{i(1+i)^n}{(1+i)^n-1} = \frac{0.1(1.1)^{20}}{(1.1)^{20}-1} = \frac{0.1\times6.7275}{5.7275} = 0.11746

The annual capital charge is (tower cost + conductor cost) × 0.11746. The annual loss cost is the energy lost per year × the energy rate.

The annual loss cost is (energy lost in 1000 kWh) × Rs 9.0, in 1000 Rs.

Annual cost comparison

ConductorCapital (1000 Rs/km)Annual capital charge (1000 Rs)Annual energy loss cost (1000 Rs)Total annual cost (1000 Rs/km)
Goat2144251.8332 × 9.0 = 288.00539.83
Sheep2386280.2627 × 9.0 = 243.00523.26
Zebra2559300.5824 × 9.0 = 216.00516.58
Deer2627308.5724 × 9.0 = 216.00524.57
Elk2815330.6521 × 9.0 = 189.00519.65

Sample (Zebra): 2559×0.11746=300.582559\times0.11746 = 300.58 and 24×9.0=216.0024\times9.0 = 216.00, total 516.58 thousand Rs/km per year.

Deer has the same loss as Zebra but costs more, so it is ruled out. Elk has the lowest loss, but its extra capital charge (about Rs 30 thousand per year) exceeds its loss saving (Rs 27 thousand per year). Zebra gives the best balance.

Answer: choose Zebra, with a minimum total annual cost of Rs 516.58 thousand per km.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transmission and Distribution System Design chapter 4 questions →