Skip to main content

Two-mass system X/F with F-V and F-I analogy

Short answer

The transfer function is X(s)/F(s) = [B(K2+K3)s + K2K3] / Δ(s) with Δ(s) a fifth-order polynomial. The force-current analogous circuit has a current source f, capacitors M1 and M2, inductors 1/K1, 1/K2, 1/K3, and resistor 1/B, with nodes for velocities.

Find transfer function for the following mechanical system considering displacement of mass M2 as output of the system. Also develop force current analogous circuit. [Figure: wall – spring K1 – mass M1 (force f(t) applied); M1 connected to mass M2 (displacement x) through spring K2 in parallel with a series combination of damper B and spring K3]

Assumptions: the masses have no friction with the ground; x1x_1 is the displacement of M1M_1, xx the displacement of M2M_2, and x3x_3 the displacement of the junction between damper BB and spring K3K_3 (B on the M1M_1 side).

Equations of motion (Laplace, zero initial conditions)

Mass M1M_1:

F(s)=(M1s2+K1)X1+K2(X1−X)+Bs(X1−X3)F(s) = (M_1s^2 + K_1)X_1 + K_2(X_1 - X) + Bs(X_1 - X_3)

Junction (x3x_3, massless):   Bs(X3−X1)+K3(X3−X)=0\;Bs(X_3 - X_1) + K_3(X_3 - X) = 0

Mass M2M_2:   M2s2X+K2(X−X1)+K3(X−X3)=0\;M_2s^2X + K_2(X - X_1) + K_3(X - X_3) = 0

Solving

The series BB–K3K_3 branch acts as an equivalent spring BsK3Bs+K3\dfrac{BsK_3}{Bs+K_3}. Together with K2K_2 in parallel, the coupling between the masses is

Kc(s)=K2+BK3sBs+K3=N(s)Bs+K3,N(s)=B(K2+K3)s+K2K3K_c(s) = K_2 + \frac{BK_3s}{Bs+K_3} = \frac{N(s)}{Bs+K_3}, \quad N(s) = B(K_2+K_3)s + K_2K_3

The two mass equations become (M1s2+K1+Kc)X1−KcX=F(M_1s^2+K_1+K_c)X_1 - K_cX = F and −KcX1+(M2s2+Kc)X=0-K_cX_1 + (M_2s^2+K_c)X = 0. So

X(s)F(s)=Kc(M1s2+K1+Kc)(M2s2+Kc)−Kc2=Kc(M1s2+K1)(M2s2+Kc)+KcM2s2\frac{X(s)}{F(s)} = \frac{K_c}{(M_1s^2+K_1+K_c)(M_2s^2+K_c) - K_c^2} = \frac{K_c}{(M_1s^2+K_1)(M_2s^2+K_c) + K_cM_2s^2}

Multiplying top and bottom by (Bs+K3)(Bs+K_3) and expanding:

X(s)F(s)=B(K2+K3)s+K2K3Δ(s)\frac{X(s)}{F(s)} = \frac{B(K_2+K_3)s + K_2K_3}{\Delta(s)} Δ(s)=BM1M2s5+K3M1M2s4+B[K1M2+(K2+K3)(M1+M2)]s3+K3[K1M2+K2(M1+M2)]s2+BK1(K2+K3)s+K1K2K3\begin{aligned} \Delta(s) ={}& BM_1M_2s^5 + K_3M_1M_2s^4 + B\left[K_1M_2 + (K_2+K_3)(M_1+M_2)\right]s^3 \\ &+ K_3\left[K_1M_2 + K_2(M_1+M_2)\right]s^2 + BK_1(K_2+K_3)s + K_1K_2K_3 \end{aligned}

Force–voltage (F-V) analogy

Force → voltage, mass → inductance L=ML = M, damper → resistance R=BR = B, spring → capacitance C=1/KC = 1/K, velocity → loop current. Mechanical parallel → electrical series and vice versa, so the coupling becomes C2C_2 in series with (R∥C3R \parallel C_3).

  +--[L1]--[C1]--+--[L2]--+
  |              |        |
 (f) i1->       C2   <-i2 |
  |              |        |
  |           +--+--+     |
  |           R     C3    |
  |           +--+--+     |
  |              |        |
  +--------------+--------+
 L1=M1, C1=1/K1, C2=1/K2, R=B, C3=1/K3, L2=M2

Force–current (F-I) analogy

Force → current source, mass → capacitance C=MC = M, damper → conductance (R=1/BR = 1/B), spring → inductance L=1/KL = 1/K, velocity → node voltage. Each displacement point becomes a node.

     v1                v3             v2
  +---o---+---[R]------o-----[L3]---+---o
  |   |   |                         |   |
  |   |   +----------[L2]-----------+   |
  |   |   |                             |
 (f)  C1  L1                            C2
  |   |   |                             |
  +---+---+-----------------------------+
            ground (reference)
 C1=M1, L1=1/K1, L2=1/K2, R=1/B, L3=1/K3, C2=M2

Node equation at v1v_1, for example: f=M1v˙1+K1 ⁣∫v1dt+K2 ⁣∫(v1−v2)dt+B(v1−v3)f = M_1\dot v_1 + K_1\!\int v_1dt + K_2\!\int(v_1-v_2)dt + B(v_1-v_3), which matches the force equation of M1M_1 with v=x˙v = \dot x.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 2 questions →