Skip to main content

Direct versus indirect band gap semiconductors

Short answer

Direct band gap: conduction band minimum and valence band maximum at same crystal momentum k. Electron-hole recombination emits a photon efficiently (e.g., GaAs, InP). Indirect band gap: band edges at different k; recombination requires a phonon for momentum conservation, making light emission poor (e.g., Si, Ge).

Differentiate between direct and indirect band gap semiconductors with examples.

A semiconductor is direct band gap if the minimum of the conduction band and the maximum of the valence band occur at the same crystal momentum k; it is indirect band gap if they occur at different k values.

   Direct (GaAs)          Indirect (Si)
  E                      E
  |   \   /  CB          |        \   /  CB
  |    \_/               |         \_/
  |     |  hv            |  ___      ^
  |    /^\               | /   \  phonon
  |   /   \  VB          |/     \ needed
  +---------- k          +------------ k
      same k              k(max) != k(min)

Comparison

PointDirect band gapIndirect band gap
Band edgesCB min and VB max at same kAt different k
TransitionElectron drops straight downNeeds a change in momentum
Third particleNot neededPhonon (lattice vibration) needed
RecombinationRadiative: energy out as photonMostly non-radiative: energy out as heat
Recombination rateHigh, short lifetime (ns)Low, long lifetime (µs–ms)
Light emissionEfficientVery poor
Absorption edgeSharp, strongGradual, weak
UsesLEDs, laser diodes, photodetectorsDiodes, transistors, ICs, solar cells
ExamplesGaAs (1.42 eV), InP, GaN, CdSSi (1.1 eV), Ge (0.66 eV), GaP

Key point

In a direct gap material an electron at the bottom of the CB can recombine with a hole at the top of the VB and give out a photon of energy hν≈Egh\nu \approx E_g while conserving momentum. In an indirect material the photon carries almost no momentum, so a phonon must take part; this three-body process is unlikely, which is why silicon cannot be used to make efficient LEDs or lasers.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Electrical Engineering Material chapter 6 questions →