- 2078 Kartik · 4 marks
Direct versus indirect band gap semiconductors
Short answer
Direct band gap: conduction band minimum and valence band maximum at same crystal momentum k. Electron-hole recombination emits a photon efficiently (e.g., GaAs, InP). Indirect band gap: band edges at different k; recombination requires a phonon for momentum conservation, making light emission poor (e.g., Si, Ge).
Differentiate between direct and indirect band gap semiconductors with examples.
A semiconductor is direct band gap if the minimum of the conduction band and the maximum of the valence band occur at the same crystal momentum k; it is indirect band gap if they occur at different k values.
Direct (GaAs) Indirect (Si)
E E
| \ / CB | \ / CB
| \_/ | \_/
| | hv | ___ ^
| /^\ | / \ phonon
| / \ VB |/ \ needed
+---------- k +------------ k
same k k(max) != k(min)
Comparison
| Point | Direct band gap | Indirect band gap |
|---|---|---|
| Band edges | CB min and VB max at same k | At different k |
| Transition | Electron drops straight down | Needs a change in momentum |
| Third particle | Not needed | Phonon (lattice vibration) needed |
| Recombination | Radiative: energy out as photon | Mostly non-radiative: energy out as heat |
| Recombination rate | High, short lifetime (ns) | Low, long lifetime (µs–ms) |
| Light emission | Efficient | Very poor |
| Absorption edge | Sharp, strong | Gradual, weak |
| Uses | LEDs, laser diodes, photodetectors | Diodes, transistors, ICs, solar cells |
| Examples | GaAs (1.42 eV), InP, GaN, CdS | Si (1.1 eV), Ge (0.66 eV), GaP |
Key point
In a direct gap material an electron at the bottom of the CB can recombine with a hole at the top of the VB and give out a photon of energy while conserving momentum. In an indirect material the photon carries almost no momentum, so a phonon must take part; this three-body process is unlikely, which is why silicon cannot be used to make efficient LEDs or lasers.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Degenerate semiconductors; direct vs indirect bandgap · Electrical Engineering Material, chapter 6
- Direct and indirect recombination · Electrical Engineering Material, chapter 6
- Degenerate versus non-degenerate semiconductors · Electrical Engineering Material, chapter 6 · asked 5×
- Fermi level at middle of band gap · Electrical Engineering Material, chapter 6
- Band bending in semiconductors · Electrical Engineering Material, chapter 6
- Si versus GaAs semiconductors · Electrical Engineering Material, chapter 6 · asked 2×
- Direct and indirect recursion · Data Structure and Algorithm, chapter 5
- Define recursion; direct vs indirect · Data Structure and Algorithm, chapter 5
- Band gap reference source and comparison with Zener · Electronics Devices and Circuit, chapter 6 · asked 2×
- Direct, indirect, deflection and null methods · Instrumentation and Measurement, chapter 1