Skip to main content

Rigid bar AB hinged at A: 100 kN

Short answer

By moment equilibrium about hinge A and compatibility δ_c = 3 δ_s, forces are 142.86 kN in steel and 85.71 kN in copper. Stresses: σ_s = 142.86 MPa, σ_c = 107.14 MPa. Reaction at A is 128.57 kN downward.

A rigid bar AB is hinged at A and supported by a 2m long copper rod and a 1m long steel rod. It carries a load of 100 KN at the free end B as shown in figure below. If the area of cross-section of the steel and copper rods be 10 cm210\ \text{cm}^2 and 8 cm28\ \text{cm}^2 respectively and their respective values of E be 200 GN/m2200\ \text{GN/m}^2 and 100 GN/m2100\ \text{GN/m}^2, find stresses in each rod and reaction at A (assume no bending in steel and copper rods). [Figure: horizontal rigid bar B-A with hinge at A (right end); a copper rod (2 m long) and a steel rod (1 m long) connect the bar to the ceiling, spaced 1 m, 2 m and 1 m along the bar from B; 100 kN load at B.]

Assumptions (from the figure): measured from B the supports are at 1 m (copper rod, 2 m long), then 3 m (steel rod, 1 m long), and the hinge A is at 4 m. So the lever arms from A are: steel 1 m, copper 3 m, load 4 m. Both rods are in tension and the bar is rigid.

Data: As=1000 mm2A_s = 1000\ \text{mm}^2, Ac=800 mm2A_c = 800\ \text{mm}^2, Es=200 GPaE_s = 200\ \text{GPa}, Ec=100 GPaE_c = 100\ \text{GPa}, Ls=1L_s = 1 m, Lc=2L_c = 2 m.

Equilibrium (moments about A)

Fs(1)+Fc(3)=100(4)=400 kN⋅mF_s(1) + F_c(3) = 100(4) = 400\ \text{kN·m}

Compatibility

The rigid bar rotates about A, so δc=3δs\delta_c = 3\delta_s:

FcLcAcEc=3 FsLsAsEs⇒Fc(2)800×10−6(100×109)=3 Fs(1)1000×10−6(200×109)\frac{F_c L_c}{A_cE_c} = 3\,\frac{F_s L_s}{A_sE_s} \Rightarrow \frac{F_c(2)}{800\times10^{-6}(100\times10^9)} = 3\,\frac{F_s(1)}{1000\times10^{-6}(200\times10^9)} Fc=0.6 FsF_c = 0.6\,F_s

Forces and stresses

Fs+3(0.6Fs)=400⇒2.8Fs=400F_s + 3(0.6F_s) = 400 \Rightarrow 2.8F_s = 400

Fs=142.86 kN,Fc=85.71 kNF_s = 142.86\ \text{kN}, \qquad F_c = 85.71\ \text{kN} σs=1428571000=142.86 MPa,σc=85714800=107.14 MPa\sigma_s = \frac{142857}{1000} = 142.86\ \text{MPa}, \qquad \sigma_c = \frac{85714}{800} = 107.14\ \text{MPa}

Reaction at A

ΣV=0:RA=Fs+Fc−100=142.86+85.71−100=128.57 kN\Sigma V = 0: \quad R_A = F_s + F_c - 100 = 142.86 + 85.71 - 100 = 128.57\ \text{kN}

The rods pull the bar up with more than the 100 kN load, so RAR_A acts downward.

Answer: σs=142.86 MPa\sigma_s = 142.86\ \text{MPa}, σc=107.14 MPa\sigma_c = 107.14\ \text{MPa} (both tensile), RA=128.57 kNR_A = 128.57\ \text{kN} downward.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Strength of Materials chapter 3 questions →