Skip to main content

Rigid bar ABCD with brass and steel rods

Short answer

Equilibrium: Fb×2 + Fs×4 =75 kN·m. Compatibility: deflection of C is twice B, giving Fs =1.6Fb. Solving yields σbrass =8.93 N/mm² (tension) and σsteel =23.81 N/mm² (compression).

A rigid bar 'ABCD' is supported at 'A' and connected with a brass rod BE and a steel rod CF at 'B' and 'C' respectively as shown in the figure. A load of 15 kN is applied at 'D'. Find the magnitude of stress in the brass rod and for the steel rod. Take Ab=1000 mm2A_b = 1000\ \text{mm}^2, As=600 mm2A_s = 600\ \text{mm}^2, Eb=100 kN/mm2E_b = 100\ \text{kN/mm}^2 and Es=200 kN/mm2E_s = 200\ \text{kN/mm}^2. [Figure: horizontal rigid bar A-B-C-D with pin at A; A to B 2 m, B to C 2 m, C to D 1 m; brass rod BE of length 2 m hung from the ceiling at B; steel rod CF of length 3 m connecting C down to the ground at F; 15 kN downward load at D.]

The load at D turns the bar clockwise about the pin A: B moves down and stretches the brass rod BE (tension, hung from the ceiling); C moves down and compresses the steel rod CF (standing on the ground). Let the forces be FbF_b (tension) and FsF_s (compression); the distances from A are B = 2 m, C = 4 m and D = 5 m.

 ceiling ==========E==================
                   |
                   | brass (2 m)
 A-------2m--------B-------2m-------C---1m---D
 (pin)                              |        | 15 kN
                                    |        v
                                    | steel (3 m)
 ground ============================F=========

Equilibrium (moments about A)

Both rods resist the load (brass pulls B up, steel pushes C up):

Fb(2)+Fs(4)=15×5=75 kN⋅mF_b(2) + F_s(4) = 15\times5 = 75\ \text{kN·m}

Compatibility

The bar is rigid, so the deflection is proportional to the distance from A: δC=2δB\delta_C = 2\delta_B.

Fs(3000)600×200=2 Fb(2000)1000×100  ⇒  25 Fs=40 Fb  ⇒  Fs=1.60 Fb\frac{F_s(3000)}{600\times200} = 2\,\frac{F_b(2000)}{1000\times100} \;\Rightarrow\; 25\,F_s = 40\,F_b \;\Rightarrow\; F_s = 1.60\,F_b

(forces in kN with E in kN/mm²; both sides multiplied by 1000).

Solution

2Fb+4(1.6Fb)=75⇒Fb=8.929 kN,Fs=14.286 kNσb=8928.61000=8.93 N/mm2σs=14285.7600=23.81 N/mm2\begin{aligned} 2F_b + 4(1.6F_b) &= 75 \Rightarrow F_b = 8.929\ \text{kN},\quad F_s = 14.286\ \text{kN}\\ \sigma_b &= \frac{8928.6}{1000} = 8.93\ \text{N/mm}^2\\ \sigma_s &= \frac{14285.7}{600} = 23.81\ \text{N/mm}^2 \end{aligned}

Answer: σbrass=8.93\sigma_{brass} = 8.93 N/mm² (tension) and σsteel=23.81\sigma_{steel} = 23.81 N/mm² (compression).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Strength of Materials chapter 3 questions →