Skip to main content

Rigid bar pinned at B with two vertical rods

Short answer

Moment equilibrium about B gives Fal + Fst = 250 N. Compatibility requires equal deflection, leading to Fal = 0.45 Fst. Solving yields σsteel = 0.862 N/mm² (tension) and σaluminium = 0.259 N/mm² (tension).

A rigid bar ABCD pinned at B and connected to two vertical rods as shown in the figure below. Assuming that the bar was initially horizontal and the rods stress free, determine the stress in each rod after the load P=500 NP = 500\ \text{N} is applied. Esteel=200 GPaE_{steel} = 200\ \text{GPa} and Eal=100 GPaE_{al} = 100\ \text{GPa}. [Figure: horizontal rigid bar A-B-C-D with pin support at B; A to B 1.5 m, B to C 0.75 m, C to D 0.75 m; aluminium rod at A (area 300 mm2300\ \text{mm}^2, length 1.5 m) fixed to the ground below; steel rod at D (area 200 mm2200\ \text{mm}^2, length 0.9 m) hanging from the ceiling; load P=500 NP = 500\ \text{N} downward at C.]

The load PP at C rotates the rigid bar clockwise about the pin B: A moves up (stretching the aluminium rod fixed to the ground below) and D moves down (stretching the steel rod hung from the ceiling). Both rods are in tension; let the forces be FalF_{al} and FstF_{st}.

 F_al                    F_st
  |                        ^
  v                        |
  A---1.5m---B---0.75---C---0.75---D
   (Al, 1.5 m)  pin     P=500 N  (steel, 0.9 m)

Equilibrium (moments about B)

Aluminium pulls A down and steel pulls D up; both give anticlockwise moments about B, balancing the clockwise moment of PP:

Fal(1.5)+Fst(1.5)=P(0.75)=500×0.75F_{al}(1.5) + F_{st}(1.5) = P(0.75) = 500\times0.75 Fal+Fst=250 NF_{al} + F_{st} = 250\ \text{N}

Compatibility

The bar is rigid, and A and D are both 1.5 m from the pin, so the upward movement of A equals the downward movement of D: δal=δst\delta_{al} = \delta_{st}.

Fal(1500)300×100×103=Fst(900)200×200×103  ⇒  5×10−5Fal=2.25×10−5Fst  ⇒  Fal=0.450 Fst\frac{F_{al}(1500)}{300\times100\times10^3} = \frac{F_{st}(900)}{200\times200\times10^3} \;\Rightarrow\; 5\times10^{-5}F_{al} = 2.25\times10^{-5}F_{st} \;\Rightarrow\; F_{al} = 0.450\,F_{st}

Solution

Fst(1+0.450)=250⇒Fst=172.41 NFal=77.59 Nσst=172.41200=0.862 N/mm2σal=77.59300=0.259 N/mm2\begin{aligned} F_{st}(1+0.450) &= 250 \Rightarrow F_{st} = 172.41\ \text{N}\\ F_{al} &= 77.59\ \text{N}\\ \sigma_{st} &= \frac{172.41}{200} = 0.862\ \text{N/mm}^2\\ \sigma_{al} &= \frac{77.59}{300} = 0.259\ \text{N/mm}^2 \end{aligned}

Answer: σsteel=0.862\sigma_{steel} = 0.862 N/mm² (tension) and σaluminium=0.259\sigma_{aluminium} = 0.259 N/mm² (tension).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Strength of Materials chapter 3 questions →