Skip to main content

Fixed shaft: end couples, diameter, section of no twist

Short answer

End fixing couples: at A 0.714 kN·m opposite to TB, at D 10.714 kN·m in the same sense as TB. Maximum torque 14.286 kN·m gives shaft diameter 113.3 mm. Zero twist occurs 0.075 m from B towards C.

Determine the end fixing couples, diameter of the shaft if the maximum shearing stress is not to exceed 50 MN/m250\ \text{MN/m}^2 and the position of the section where the shaft suffers no angular twist. [Figure: shaft fixed at both ends A and D; torque TB=15 kNmT_B = 15\ \text{kNm} at B and torque TB=25 kNmT_B = 25\ \text{kNm} (printed as TBT_B, read as the torque at C) at C in the opposite sense; A to B 1.5 m, B to C 1.2 m, C to D 1.5 m.]

Reading of the figure: shaft of uniform diameter fixed at A and D; TB=15T_B = 15 kN·m at B and TC=25T_C = 25 kN·m at C (opposite sense to TBT_B); AB=1.5AB = 1.5 m, BC=1.2BC = 1.2 m, CD=1.5CD = 1.5 m; τmax=50 MN/m2\tau_{max} = 50\ \text{MN/m}^2.

End fixing couples

Let TAT_A be the reaction at A (positive in the sense of TBT_B). The torques in the segments are

TAB=TA,TBC=TA+15,TCD=TA+15−25=TA−10(kN⋅m)T_{AB} = T_A, \qquad T_{BC} = T_A + 15, \qquad T_{CD} = T_A + 15 - 25 = T_A - 10 \quad(\text{kN·m})

The ends are fixed, so the total twist is zero. GG and JJ are constant:

TA(1.5)+(TA+15)(1.2)+(TA−10)(1.5)=0⇒4.2 TA+3=0⇒TA=−0.714 kN⋅mT_A(1.5) + (T_A+15)(1.2) + (T_A-10)(1.5) = 0 \Rightarrow 4.2\,T_A + 3 = 0 \Rightarrow T_A = -0.714\ \text{kN·m}

The negative sign means the reaction at A acts opposite to TBT_B. Also TD=10.714T_D = 10.714 kN·m from equilibrium (TA+TD+15−25=0T_A + T_D + 15 - 25 = 0 with the signs above).

SegmentTorque (kN·m)
AB-0.714
BC14.286
CD-10.714

Answer (end couples): ∣TA∣=0.714|T_A| = 0.714 kN·m, acting opposite to TBT_B; ∣TD∣=10.714|T_D| = 10.714 kN·m, acting in the same sense as TBT_B.

Diameter

The maximum torque is TBC=14.286T_{BC} = 14.286 kN·m.

d3=16Tmaxπτ=16(1.4286×107)π(50)=1.4551×106 mm3⇒d=113.32 mmd^3 = \frac{16T_{max}}{\pi\tau} = \frac{16(1.4286\times10^{7})}{\pi(50)} = 1.4551\times10^{6}\ \text{mm}^3 \Rightarrow d = 113.32\ \text{mm}

Section with no angular twist

The rotation of a section relative to A is φ=∑TLGJ\varphi = \sum \dfrac{TL}{GJ}. At B (taking GJ=1GJ = 1 units, kN·m²): φB=0.714×1.5=1.071\varphi_B = 0.714\times1.5 = 1.071. In BC the twist changes at the rate TBC=14.286T_{BC} = 14.286 in the opposite direction, so it reaches zero at a distance

x=1.07114.286=0.075 m from Bx = \frac{1.071}{14.286} = 0.075\ \text{m from B}

Answer: the section ≈0.075\approx 0.075 m from B (i.e. 1.575 m from A, inside BC) suffers no angular twist; d≈113.3d \approx 113.3 mm.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Strength of Materials chapter 6 questions →