Skip to main content

Failure mode: HS N45E/70, bedding N55E/45

Short answer

Using assumed 30° friction angle, bedding (45/145) daylights and exceeds friction, so plane failure is main. Bedding-J2 intersection plunges 32.6° toward 195° above friction and daylights, so wedge failure also possible. Reduce cut below 45° and support.

Suggest the possible mode of failure from the following figure. Hill slope: N45°E/70°; Bedding: N55°E/45°; Joint 1: N47°W/31°; Joint 2: N77°E/36°; Joint 3: N20°E/10°. [Figure: stereonet]

Method (lower-hemisphere stereonet, equal-angle): plot the great circle of the slope face and of each discontinuity, draw the friction circle of radius ϕ\phi, and mark intersections of great circles. Then apply the kinematic tests below.

Data and assumptions

All planes strike as given and are taken to dip on the side that appears in the figure: Hill slope N45°E/70° SE = 70/135; Bedding N55°E/45° SE = 45/145; J1 N47°W/31° SW = 31/223; J2 N77°E/36° SE = 36/167; J3 N20°E/10° SE = 10/110. The friction angle is not stated, so ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ is assumed.

Single planes

Plane (dip/dip dir)Diff. of dip dir from slopeDaylights (ψp<ψf\psi_p<\psi_f)ψp>ϕ\psi_p>\phiResult
Bedding (45/145)10°yesyesPlane failure
J1 (31/223)88°yesyesSafe
J2 (36/167)32°yesyesSafe
J3 (10/110)25°yesnoSafe

Intersections

PairIntersection plunge/trendFace apparent dip along trendResult
Bedding x J129.1° / 201°48.0°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)
Bedding x J232.6° / 195°53.8°Wedge failure
Bedding x J36.7° / 062°38.4°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)
J1 x J229.8° / 205°43.1°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)
J1 x J38.1° / 147°69.6°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)
J2 x J39.4° / 090°62.8°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)

Result

  • Bedding dips 10∘10^\circ off the face direction at 45∘45^\circ: 30∘<45∘<70∘30^\circ < 45^\circ < 70^\circ, so it daylights and can slide: plane failure.
  • J3 dips only 10∘10^\circ, below ϕ\phi: stable. J1 dips across the slope (88° from the face direction).
  • The Bedding x J2 intersection plunges 32.6∘32.6^\circ towards 195°, in the face (apparent dip 53.8∘53.8^\circ) and above ϕ\phi: wedge failure is also possible.

Possible mode of failure: plane failure along the bedding planes (main), with wedge failure formed by bedding and J2. Reduce the cut angle below 45∘45^\circ and provide bolting and drainage.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Engineering Geology II chapter 6 questions →