- 2071 Magh · 5 marks
Economics of 1-φ vs 3-φ delivery
Short answer
For same power, distance, loss and voltage, three-phase 3-wire needs only 75% of the conductor of single-phase 2-wire, since Vol3/Vol1 = 3/4. Three-phase also gives more machine output per frame and cheaper transformers and motors.
Compare the economic aspects of 1-φ and 3-φ power delivery systems. Give suitable mathematical relationship to justify the argument.
For the same power, distance, line loss and maximum voltage, a 3-phase system needs less conductor material and so costs less.
Single-phase 2-wire line
Power , voltage (between conductors), p.f. , length , area :
Three-phase 3-wire line (line voltage )
Comparison
So 3-phase 3-wire needs only 75 % of the conductor of 1-phase 2-wire (with the same voltage between conductors).
Other economic points
| Aspect | 1-phase | 3-phase |
|---|---|---|
| Conductor | 100 % | 75 % |
| Machine output per frame | 1 | ≈ 1.5 |
| Transformer cost per kVA | Higher | Lower |
| Motor | Needs starting aid | Self-starting, cheaper per kW |
| Power | Pulsating | Constant |
| Use | Small domestic loads | Generation, transmission, industry |
Hence 3-phase delivery is more economical for generation, transmission and distribution; 1-phase is only used for small loads tapped from the 3-phase system.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Benefits of three-phase over single-phase delivery · Power System Analysis I, chapter 1 · asked 2×
- Vs from P+jQ and reactive power flow direction · Power System Analysis I, chapter 6
- Evolution of power systems and milestones · Power System Analysis I, chapter 1
- Infinite bus and HVDC vs HVAC comparison · Power System Analysis I, chapter 1
- Conductor volume vs voltage and power factor · Power System Analysis I, chapter 1
- Power delivered from sending end data, nominal-π · Power System Analysis I, chapter 5
- Compare AM systems; one method of DSB-FC generation · Communication Systems, chapter 2
- Justify higher voltage/more circuits for more power · Transmission and Distribution System Design, chapter 2
- Justify: series motor power; shunt motor for traction · Utilization of Electrical Energy, chapter 4
- Financial vs economic analysis; both BCR · Engineering Economics, chapter 3