Skip to main content

Vs from P+jQ and reactive power flow direction

Short answer

With V_R as reference, V_S = V_R + (RP+XQ)/V_R + j(XP−RQ)/V_R. For X ≫ R, |V_S|−|V_R| ≈ XQ/V_R, so Q ≈ V_R(|V_S|−|V_R|)/X, thus reactive power always flows from the higher voltage magnitude bus to the lower voltage magnitude bus.

Derive the expression for sending end voltage (Vs) in terms of receiving end voltage (Vr), line resistance (R) and reactance (X) and complex power (P + jQ) demand at the receiving end and hence justify that reactive power always flows from higher voltage magnitude to lower voltage magnitude.

Derivation

Short line, per phase impedance Z=R+jXZ = R + jX. Take VR=∣VR∣∠0∘V_R = |V_R|\angle0^\circ and the receiving-end demand SR=P+jQS_R = P + jQ (per phase).

Since SR=VRI∗S_R = V_RI^*,

I=P−jQVRI = \frac{P - jQ}{V_R}

Then

VS=VR+(R+jX)P−jQVR=(VR+RP+XQVR)+j(XP−RQVR)\begin{aligned} V_S &= V_R + (R + jX)\frac{P - jQ}{V_R} \\ &= \left(V_R + \frac{RP + XQ}{V_R}\right) + j\left(\frac{XP - RQ}{V_R}\right) \end{aligned}

So

∣VS∣=(VR+RP+XQVR)2+(XP−RQVR)2|V_S| = \sqrt{\left(V_R + \frac{RP + XQ}{V_R}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{XP - RQ}{V_R}\right)^2}

The first bracket is the in-phase drop ΔV=(RP+XQ)/VR\Delta V = (RP + XQ)/V_R and the second is the quadrature drop δV=(XP−RQ)/VR\delta V = (XP - RQ)/V_R.

Reactive power flows from higher to lower voltage

For transmission lines X≫RX \gg R and the quadrature part changes the magnitude very little. Then

∣VS∣−∣VR∣≈RP+XQVR≈XQVR|V_S| - |V_R| \approx \frac{RP + XQ}{V_R} \approx \frac{XQ}{V_R} ⇒ Q≈VR (∣VS∣−∣VR∣)X\Rightarrow\ Q \approx \frac{V_R\,(|V_S| - |V_R|)}{X}
  • If ∣VS∣>∣VR∣|V_S| > |V_R|: Q>0Q > 0, reactive power flows from sending end to receiving end.
  • If ∣VS∣<∣VR∣|V_S| < |V_R|: Q<0Q < 0, reactive power flows from receiving end to sending end.
  • If ∣VS∣=∣VR∣|V_S| = |V_R|: almost no reactive power transfer.

So reactive power always flows from the bus with the higher voltage magnitude to the bus with the lower voltage magnitude, whatever the phase angles. (Active power, on the other hand, follows the angle: P≈VSVRsin⁡δ/XP \approx V_SV_R\sin\delta/X.)

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Power System Analysis I chapter 6 questions →