Skip to main content

Expression for receiving-end shunt compensation

Short answer

With a receiving-end reactor jXp, Vs = Vr(cos βl + (Zc/Xp) sin βl). Setting |Vs|=|Vr| gives cos βl + (Zc/Xp) sin βl = 1. Defining θ = cos⁻¹(Xp/√(Zc²+Xp²)) yields Xp = Zc / tan(βl - θ), which is the required expression.

With suitable mathematical aid, show that neglecting the source impedance for a lossless line, the value of a shunt reactive compensation required at the receiving end at no load for sending end and receiving end voltages to be equal could be expressed as Xp = Zc / tan(βl − cos⁻¹(Xp/√(Zc² + Xp²))).

Neglect the source impedance and losses. Let a shunt reactor jXpjX_p be connected at the receiving end of a line with surge impedance ZcZ_c and electrical length βl\beta l.

Line equation with the reactor

Vs=Vrcos⁡βl+jZcIrsin⁡βlV_s = V_r\cos\beta l + jZ_c I_r\sin\beta l

At no load the only receiving-end current is the reactor current:

Ir=VrjXpI_r = \frac{V_r}{jX_p} Vs=Vr(cos⁡βl+ZcXpsin⁡βl)V_s = V_r\left(\cos\beta l + \frac{Z_c}{X_p}\sin\beta l\right)

Condition ∣Vs∣=∣Vr∣|V_s| = |V_r|

cos⁡βl+ZcXpsin⁡βl=1(1)\cos\beta l + \frac{Z_c}{X_p}\sin\beta l = 1 \qquad (1)

Define an angle θ\theta by

tan⁡θ=ZcXp,socos⁡θ=XpZc2+Xp2,sin⁡θ=ZcZc2+Xp2\tan\theta = \frac{Z_c}{X_p}, \quad\text{so}\quad \cos\theta = \frac{X_p}{\sqrt{Z_c^2 + X_p^2}}, \quad \sin\theta = \frac{Z_c}{\sqrt{Z_c^2 + X_p^2}}

that is, θ=cos⁡−1 ⁣(XpZc2+Xp2)\theta = \cos^{-1}\!\left(\dfrac{X_p}{\sqrt{Z_c^2 + X_p^2}}\right).

Multiply (1) by cos⁡θ\cos\theta:

cos⁡βlcos⁡θ+sin⁡βlsin⁡θ=cos⁡θcos⁡(βl−θ)=cos⁡θβl−θ=θ\begin{aligned} \cos\beta l\cos\theta + \sin\beta l\sin\theta &= \cos\theta \\ \cos(\beta l - \theta) &= \cos\theta \\ \beta l - \theta &= \theta \end{aligned}

So tan⁡(βl−θ)=tan⁡θ=ZcXp\tan(\beta l - \theta) = \tan\theta = \dfrac{Z_c}{X_p}, which gives

Xp=Zctan⁡(βl−cos⁡−1XpZc2+Xp2)\boxed{X_p = \frac{Z_c}{\tan\left(\beta l - \cos^{-1}\dfrac{X_p}{\sqrt{Z_c^2 + X_p^2}}\right)}}

This is the required expression.

Explicit form

From βl−θ=θ\beta l - \theta = \theta we get θ=βl/2\theta = \beta l/2, so

Xp=Zctan⁡(βl/2)=Zccot⁡βl2X_p = \frac{Z_c}{\tan(\beta l/2)} = Z_c\cot\frac{\beta l}{2}

Example: a 400 km line with Zc=316 ΩZ_c = 316\ \Omega and βl=0.397\beta l = 0.397 rad gives Xp=316/tan⁡(0.199)=1571 ΩX_p = 316/\tan(0.199) = 1571\ \Omega.

Physically, the reactor absorbs the line's charging VArs at the receiving end. Less net charging current then flows through the series inductance, which removes the Ferranti rise.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All High Voltage Engineering chapter 3 questions →