Skip to main content

Receiving-end voltage infinite at 1500 km

Short answer

For a lossless line at no load, VR = Vs/cos(beta l). With wave velocity 3e5 km/s and 50 Hz, beta = 1.047e-3 rad/km; for 1500 km beta l = 90 degrees, cos beta l = 0, so VR becomes infinite. The line is a quarter-wavelength resonant line.

Starting with the mathematical expression given below. Justify that the voltage at the receiving end of a loss less line of 50 Hz operating frequency becomes infinity when the length of line is 1500 km at no-load condition. [Vs; Is] = [A B; C D][VR; IR]

For a lossless line the ABCD constants are

[VsIs]=[cos⁡βljZcsin⁡βljsin⁡βlZccos⁡βl][VRIR]\begin{bmatrix} V_s \\ I_s \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} \cos\beta l & jZ_c\sin\beta l \\ \dfrac{j\sin\beta l}{Z_c} & \cos\beta l \end{bmatrix}\begin{bmatrix} V_R \\ I_R \end{bmatrix}

where β=ωLC\beta = \omega\sqrt{LC} is the phase constant and Zc=L/CZ_c = \sqrt{L/C} is the surge impedance.

No-load condition

At no load IR=0I_R = 0, so

Vs=AVR=VRcos⁡βl  ⇒  VR=Vscos⁡βlV_s = A V_R = V_R\cos\beta l \;\Rightarrow\; V_R = \frac{V_s}{\cos\beta l}

Phase constant for an overhead line

For a lossless overhead line the wave velocity is v=1/LC≈c=3×105v = 1/\sqrt{LC} \approx c = 3\times10^5 km/s, so

β=ωLC=ωv=2π×503×105=1.0472×10−3 rad/km  (=0.06∘/km=6∘ per 100 km)\begin{aligned} \beta &= \omega\sqrt{LC} = \frac{\omega}{v} = \frac{2\pi \times 50}{3\times10^5} \\ &= 1.0472\times10^{-3}\ \text{rad/km} \;(= 0.06^\circ/\text{km} = 6^\circ \text{ per 100 km}) \end{aligned}

Wavelength: λ=v/f=3×105/50=6000\lambda = v/f = 3\times10^5/50 = 6000 km.

Line of 1500 km

βl=1.0472×10−3×1500=1.5708 rad=90∘cos⁡βl=cos⁡90∘=0VR=Vs0→∞\begin{aligned} \beta l &= 1.0472\times10^{-3} \times 1500 = 1.5708\ \text{rad} = 90^\circ \\ \cos\beta l &= \cos 90^\circ = 0 \\ V_R &= \frac{V_s}{0} \to \infty \end{aligned}

So a 1500 km line is a quarter-wavelength line (l=λ/4=6000/4l = \lambda/4 = 6000/4). At no load it is in resonance: the line inductance and capacitance resonate at 50 Hz. In theory the receiving-end voltage is infinite, for any finite sending-end voltage.

Length (km)βl\beta lVR/VsV_R/V_s
30018°1.051
60036°1.236
100060°2.000
150090°∞

In practice line resistance and corona losses limit the voltage, but it would still be dangerously high. Very long lines are therefore compensated (shunt reactors, series capacitors) or split into sections by intermediate substations.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All High Voltage Engineering chapter 3 questions →