Skip to main content

LC lossless check; Foster and Cauer synthesis

Short answer

Z2(s) = (s²+2)(s²+10)/(s(s²+5)) is the only valid LC impedance because its simple poles and zeros lie on the jω axis, alternate (p0, z1.414, p2.236, z3.162, p∞), and degrees differ by one. Foster‑I: series 1 H, 1/4 F, parallel 3/5 H || 1/3 F. Cauer‑I: series 1 H, shunt 1/7 F, series 49/15 H, shunt 3/28 F.

Which of the following is LC lossless function and why? Pick one of the valid LC lossless functions and synthesize it using Foster and Cauer methods. i) Z1(s) = s(s²+4)(s²+9)/((s²+2)(s²+10)) ii) Z2(s) = (s²+2)(s²+10)/(s(s²+5)) iii) Z3(s) = (s²+25)/(s(s²+5)(s²+50))

Testing the functions

Tests for a valid LC impedance: (1) even/odd or odd/even ratio, (2) simple poles and zeros only on the jωj\omega axis, (3) poles and zeros alternate, (4) a pole or a zero at both s=0s=0 and s=∞s=\infty (degrees differ by exactly 1), (5) positive residues.

FunctionCritical frequenciesResult
Z1=s(s2+4)(s2+9)(s2+2)(s2+10)Z_1 = \dfrac{s(s^2+4)(s^2+9)}{(s^2+2)(s^2+10)}z 0, p 1.414, z 2, z 3, p 3.162, p ∞Zeros 2 and 3 adjacent → invalid
Z2=(s2+2)(s2+10)s(s2+5)Z_2 = \dfrac{(s^2+2)(s^2+10)}{s(s^2+5)}p 0, z 1.414, p 2.236, z 3.162, p ∞Alternate → valid
Z3=s2+25s(s2+5)(s2+50)Z_3 = \dfrac{s^2+25}{s(s^2+5)(s^2+50)}p 0, p 2.236, z 5, p 7.07Adjacent poles; degrees differ by 3 → invalid

Synthesize Z2(s)=s4+12s2+20s3+5sZ_2(s) = \dfrac{s^4+12s^2+20}{s^3+5s}.

Foster (Foster-I) form

Expand Z(s)Z(s) in partial fractions (each term is an impedance; the elements are in series):

k∞=[Z(s)s]s→∞=1k0=[s Z(s)]s=0=42k3=[(s2+5) Z(s)s]s2=−5=3\begin{aligned} k_\infty &= \left[\frac{Z(s)}{s}\right]_{s\to\infty} = 1 \\ k_0 &= \left[s\,Z(s)\right]_{s=0} = 4 \\ 2k_{3} &= \left[\frac{(s^2+5)\,Z(s)}{s}\right]_{s^2=-5} = 3 \end{aligned} Z(s)=s+4s+3ss2+5Z(s) = s + \frac{4}{s} + \frac{3 s}{s^{2} + 5}
TermRuleElement value
L1L_1 (series, pole at ∞\infty)k∞k_\infty1 H
C2C_2 (series, pole at 0)1/k01/k_01/4 F (≈ 0.25 F)
L3∥C3L_3 \parallel C_3 (tank, ω2=5\omega^2=5)C=1/2kC=1/2k, L=2k/ω2L=2k/\omega^2C3C_3 = 1/3 F (≈ 0.3333 F), L3L_3 = 3/5 H (≈ 0.6 H)
o--[L1]--[C2]--[L3||C3]--o

Cauer (Cauer-I) form

Z(s)Z(s) has a pole at s=∞s=\infty (numerator degree is higher), so the first element is a series inductor. Divide repeatedly with polynomials in descending powers (continued fraction about s=∞s=\infty), inverting the remainder each time:

  1. Z1(s)=s4+12s2+20s3+5sZ_1(s) = \frac{s^{4} + 12 s^{2} + 20}{s^{3} + 5 s} → quotient ss gives series L1L_1 = 1 H; remainder 7s2+20s(s2+5)\frac{7 s^{2} + 20}{s \left(s^{2} + 5\right)}.
  2. Y2(s)=s3+5s7s2+20Y_2(s) = \frac{s^{3} + 5 s}{7 s^{2} + 20} → quotient s7\frac{s}{7} gives shunt C2C_2 = 1/7 F (≈ 0.1429 F); remainder 15s7(7s2+20)\frac{15 s}{7 \left(7 s^{2} + 20\right)}.
  3. Z3(s)=49s2+14015sZ_3(s) = \frac{49 s^{2} + 140}{15 s} → quotient 49s15\frac{49 s}{15} gives series L3L_3 = 49/15 H (≈ 3.267 H); remainder 283s\frac{28}{3 s}.
  4. Y4(s)=3s28Y_4(s) = \frac{3 s}{28} → quotient 3s28\frac{3 s}{28} gives shunt C4C_4 = 3/28 F (≈ 0.1071 F); remainder 00.
ElementPositionValue
L1L_1series1 H
C2C_2shunt1/7 F (≈ 0.1429 F)
L3L_3series49/15 H (≈ 3.267 H)
C4C_4shunt3/28 F (≈ 0.1071 F)
o--[L1]----+---[L3]----+
           |           |
         [C2]        [C4]
           |           |
o----------+-----------+

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Filter Design chapter 4 questions →