Skip to main content

Line currents with isolated and grounded neutral

Short answer

For Z=10 Ω/phase, sequence voltages found: V0=30.66∠-11.79° V, V1=198.08∠0.33° V, V2=9.56∠147.73° V. (a) Isolated neutral: I0=0, Ia=19.01∠1.89° A, Ib=20.66∠-118.44° A, Ic=19.79∠117.57° A. (b) Solidly grounded: Ia=22.0∠0° A, Ib=20.0∠-110° A, Ic=18.0∠110° A, In=9.20∠-11.79° A.

Across a symmetrical star connected impedance system with Z = 10 ohms in each phase, a three phase unbalanced system of Voltages with Va = 220∠0°, Vb = 200∠−110° & Vc = 180∠+110° volts is applied. Determine the line currents if the system neutral is (a) isolated (b) solidly grounded.

For a symmetrical star load, Z1=Z2=ZZ_1 = Z_2 = Z and Z0=Z+3ZnZ_0 = Z + 3Z_n. With an isolated neutral Zn=∞Z_n = \infty, so no zero sequence current flows; with a solidly grounded neutral each phase current is simply V/ZV/Z.

Assumption: the applied voltages are phase-to-ground (supply neutral grounded) voltages, Z=10 ΩZ = 10\ \Omega resistive.

Sequence components of the applied voltages

Va=220∠0∘=220+j0Vb=200∠−110∘=−68.40−j187.94Vc=180∠110∘=−61.56+j169.14\begin{aligned} V_a &= 220\angle0^\circ = 220 + j0 \\ V_b &= 200\angle{-110^\circ} = -68.40 - j187.94 \\ V_c &= 180\angle110^\circ = -61.56 + j169.14 \end{aligned} V0=13(Va+Vb+Vc)=30.01−j6.26=30.66∠−11.79∘ VV1=13(Va+aVb+a2Vc)=198.08+j1.16=198.08∠0.33∘ VV2=13(Va+a2Vb+aVc)=−8.09+j5.11=9.56∠147.73∘ V\begin{aligned} V_0 &= \tfrac13(V_a+V_b+V_c) = 30.01 - j6.26 = 30.66\angle{-11.79^\circ}\ \text{V} \\ V_1 &= \tfrac13(V_a+aV_b+a^2V_c) = 198.08 + j1.16 = 198.08\angle0.33^\circ\ \text{V} \\ V_2 &= \tfrac13(V_a+a^2V_b+aV_c) = -8.09 + j5.11 = 9.56\angle147.73^\circ\ \text{V} \end{aligned}

(a) Neutral isolated

Zero sequence current cannot flow (I0=0I_0 = 0); the zero sequence voltage appears as the neutral shift VnN=V0=30.66∠−11.79∘V_{nN} = V_0 = 30.66\angle{-11.79^\circ} V.

I1=V1Z=19.81+j0.12 A,I2=V2Z=−0.81+j0.51 AIa=I1+I2=19.00+j0.63=19.01∠1.89∘ AIb=a2I1+aI2=−9.84−j18.17=20.66∠−118.44∘ AIc=aI1+a2I2=−9.16+j17.54=19.79∠117.57∘ A\begin{aligned} I_1 &= \frac{V_1}{Z} = 19.81 + j0.12\ \text{A}, \qquad I_2 = \frac{V_2}{Z} = -0.81 + j0.51\ \text{A} \\ I_a &= I_1 + I_2 = 19.00 + j0.63 = 19.01\angle1.89^\circ\ \text{A} \\ I_b &= a^2I_1 + aI_2 = -9.84 - j18.17 = 20.66\angle{-118.44^\circ}\ \text{A} \\ I_c &= aI_1 + a^2I_2 = -9.16 + j17.54 = 19.79\angle117.57^\circ\ \text{A} \end{aligned}

Check: Ia+Ib+Ic=0I_a + I_b + I_c = 0 ✓

(b) Neutral solidly grounded

Z0=Z1=Z2=10 ΩZ_0 = Z_1 = Z_2 = 10\ \Omega, so each phase sees its own voltage:

Ia=220∠0∘10=22.0∠0∘ AIb=200∠−110∘10=20.0∠−110∘ AIc=180∠110∘10=18.0∠110∘ A\begin{aligned} I_a &= \frac{220\angle0^\circ}{10} = 22.0\angle0^\circ\ \text{A} \\ I_b &= \frac{200\angle{-110^\circ}}{10} = 20.0\angle{-110^\circ}\ \text{A} \\ I_c &= \frac{180\angle110^\circ}{10} = 18.0\angle110^\circ\ \text{A} \end{aligned}

Neutral current: In=Ia+Ib+Ic=3V0/Z=9.00−j1.88=9.20∠−11.79∘I_n = I_a + I_b + I_c = 3V_0/Z = 9.00 - j1.88 = 9.20\angle{-11.79^\circ} A.

Line currentIsolated neutralSolidly grounded
IaI_a19.01∠1.89° A22.0∠0° A
IbI_b20.66∠−118.44° A20.0∠−110° A
IcI_c19.79∠117.57° A18.0∠110° A
InI_n09.20∠−11.79° A

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Power System Analysis II chapter 4 questions →