Skip to main content

Moment distribution: frame with 50 kNm

Short answer

Overhang BC fixed-end moment -375 kNm. Moment distribution at joint B with DF_BA=0.6, DF_BD=0.4, carry-over yields final clockwise end moments: M_AB=107.50 kNm, M_BA=231.67 kNm, M_BC=-375.00 kNm, M_BD=143.33 kNm, M_DB=71.67 kNm.

Draw the bending moment diagram of the frame given below using the moment distribution method. [Figure: horizontal member A-B-C with A fixed; AB (1.5I) carries a 50 kNm moment, dimensions 2 m and 4 m as marked; BC (2I) of 5 m carries 30 kN/m UDL; column BD (I) of height 6 m, fixed at D.]

Assumptions: AB = 2 m + 4 m = 6 m (A fixed) carries a clockwise couple of 50 kNm at 2 m from A; BC = 5 m is a free-ended overhang with 30 kN/m; the column BD = 6 m is fixed at D. Relative stiffness: AB = 1.5I, BC = 2I, BD = I (E constant). No sway occurs because the fixed support at A prevents the horizontal movement of the girder.

Step 1: Overhang BC

The overhang is statically determinate: MBC=30×522=375M_{BC}=\dfrac{30\times5^2}{2}=375 kNm (hogging). It is a fixed moment on joint B and takes no part in the distribution (DF = 0).

Step 2: Stiffness and distribution factors (only joint B is free)

  • Joint B: relative stiffness Σk\Sigma k = 0.4167; BA: k=EI/Lk=EI/L = 0.2500, DF = 0.6000; BC: overhang, DF = 0 (its moment is a known fixed value); BD: k=EI/Lk=EI/L = 0.1667, DF = 0.4000

Step 3: Fixed-end moments (clockwise +)

For a couple MM at distance aa from A: FEMAB=Mb(2a−b)L2FEM_{AB}=\dfrac{Mb(2a-b)}{L^2}, FEMBA=Ma(2b−a)L2FEM_{BA}=\dfrac{Ma(2b-a)}{L^2} with a=2a=2, b=4b=4, L=6L=6: FEMAB=50×4×(4−4)36=0FEM_{AB}=\dfrac{50\times4\times(4-4)}{36}=0, FEMBA=50×2×(8−2)36=16.67FEM_{BA}=\dfrac{50\times2\times(8-2)}{36}=16.67 kNm. Overhang moment on B: −375-375 kNm. Column BD has no load.

Step 4: Moment distribution

Unbalanced moment at B = 16.67−375=−358.3316.67-375=-358.33 kNm, so the balancing moment is +358.33+358.33 kNm, shared 0.6 : 0.4. Half of each share is carried over to the far fixed ends.

ABBABCBDDB
DF-0.6000.0000.400-
FEM0.0016.67-375.000.000.00
Balance0.00215.000.00143.330.00
Carry-over107.500.000.000.0071.67
Final M107.50231.67-375.00143.3371.67

Step 5: Bending moment diagram (kNm)

  • Joint B: 231.67+143.33−375=0231.67+143.33-375=0 ✓
  • Column BD: top moment 143.33, base moment 71.67 (carry-over of one half)
  • Overhang: 375 kNm at B (statics)
MemberBM at first endBM at second endMax within member
AB107.50-231.67jump at 2.00 m: -22.22 just left, +27.78 just right of the couple
BC-375.000.00-
BD143.33-71.67-

BM sign: positive = tension on the right-hand side when travelling A to B to C and B to D (sagging for the horizontal beam). In AB the shear is constant, VA=−(107.50+231.67+50)/6=−64.86V_A=-(107.50+231.67+50)/6=-64.86 kN, so the BMD is two parallel straight lines: from 107.50 at A to -22.22 just left of the couple, then a jump of +50 (the clockwise couple) to +27.78, then down to -231.67 at B. The overhang BC has a parabolic diagram from 0 at C to 375 kNm (hogging) at B.

Answer: MAB=107.50M_{AB}=107.50, MBA=231.67M_{BA}=231.67, MBC=−375.00M_{BC}=-375.00, MBD=143.33M_{BD}=143.33, MDB=71.67M_{DB}=71.67 kNm (clockwise end moments +).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures II chapter 3 questions →