Skip to main content

Check 200x200 Debdar column, 30 kN + 1.5 kNm

Short answer

Column is safe. Permissible axial stress 6.64 N/mm² (intermediate column), bending 8.70 N/mm²; combined stress ratio 0.24 < 1.

Check the safety of a square column 200×200 mm in cross section. The effective length of the column is 2.5 m, the axial load and bending moment in the column are 30 kN and 1.5 kN-m respectively. The material is Debdar wood and the column is located outside the building.

Approach. Combined axial compression and bending, IS 883:1994 cl. 7.7.1: the column is safe if facfc+fabfb≤1\dfrac{f_{ac}}{f_c} + \dfrac{f_{ab}}{f_b} \le 1.

Data and permissible stresses

Section 200 × 200 mm, effective length S=2500S = 2500 mm, N=30N = 30 kN, M=1.5M = 1.5 kN·m.

Species: Deodar (Cedrus deodara), Group C. Location: outside. Grade: Grade I (standard) (Table 1 values are for Grade I).

Permissible stresses (IS 883:1994 Table 1, outside location):

PropertyTable 1 value (N/mm²)Used (N/mm²)
Bending / tension along grain fbf_b8.78.70
Compression parallel to grain fcpf_{cp}6.96.90
Compression perpendicular to grain fcnf_{cn}2.12.10
Horizontal shear HH0.70.70
Modulus of elasticity EE94809480

The column is located outside the building, so the outside values are taken; the grade is not stated, so Grade I (standard).

Permissible axial stress

S/d=2500/200=12.5K8=0.584E/fcp=0.5849480/6.9=21.65\begin{aligned} S/d &= 2500/200 = 12.5 \\ K_8 &= 0.584\sqrt{E/f_{cp}} = 0.584\sqrt{9480/6.9} = 21.65 \end{aligned}

11<S/d<K811 < S/d < K_8, so it is an intermediate column:

fc=fcp[1−13(S/dK8)4]=6.9[1−13(12.521.65)4]=6.644 N/mm2f_c = f_{cp}\left[1 - \frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{S/d}{K_8}\right)^4\right] = 6.9\left[1 - \frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{12.5}{21.65}\right)^4\right] = 6.644\ \text{N/mm}^2

Actual stresses

fac=30×103200×200=0.750 N/mm2fab=6Mbd2=6×1.5×1062003=1.125 N/mm2\begin{aligned} f_{ac} &= \frac{30\times10^3}{200\times200} = 0.750\ \text{N/mm}^2 \\ f_{ab} &= \frac{6M}{bd^2} = \frac{6\times1.5\times10^6}{200^3} = 1.125\ \text{N/mm}^2 \end{aligned}

Check

facfc+fabfb=0.7506.644+1.1258.7=0.113+0.129=0.242\frac{f_{ac}}{f_c} + \frac{f_{ab}}{f_b} = \frac{0.750}{6.644} + \frac{1.125}{8.7} = 0.113 + 0.129 = 0.242

Answer: the interaction value is 0.24 < 1, so the column is safe. (Depth is 200 mm, so no form factor is applied to the bending stress.)

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Design of Steel and Timber Structure chapter 11 questions →