Skip to main content

Critical DO deficit, location, sag curve

Short answer

Mixing at 20°C gives initial deficit 1.98 mg/L, ultimate BOD 69.71 mg/L; K=0.1/d, R=0.5/d (base 10). Critical deficit = 9.61 mg/L at 111.72 km downstream (1.62 days). BOD5 at critical point = 32.85 mg/L; minimum DO becomes negative, indicating severe pollution.

From the following data find: a. Critical DO deficit. b. Location of critical DO deficit. c. BOD5 at 20°C of the sample taken at critical point. d. Draw a sag curve.

ItemEffluentStream
Discharge (m³/s)1.57.5
BOD5 20°C (mg/l)2801.2
DO (mg/l)0.290% of saturated
Temperature (°C)3018

Assume K = 0.1 day⁻¹, R = 0.5 day⁻¹ at 20°C. Saturation DO at 20°C and 18°C is 9.17 mg/l and 9.54 mg/l respectively. Velocity of river = 0.8 m/s.

Stream DO is 90% of saturation at 18°C: DOr=0.9×9.54=8.586DO_r = 0.9\times 9.54 = 8.586 mg/l. The mixture temperature is (1.5×30+7.5×18)/9=20∘(1.5\times 30+7.5\times 18)/9 = 20^\circC, so the given K=0.1K=0.1 and R=0.5R=0.5 (base 10) and DOsat=9.17DO_{sat}=9.17 mg/l apply without correction.

Step 1: Conditions just after mixing

Qmix=Qs+Qr=1.5+7.5=9 m3/sBOD5mix=QsBs+QrBrQs+Qr=1.5×280+7.5×1.29=47.67 mg/lDOmix=QsDOs+QrDOrQs+Qr=1.5×0.2+7.5×8.5869=7.19 mg/lD0=DOsat−DOmix=9.17−7.19=1.98 mg/l\begin{aligned} Q_{mix} &= Q_s+Q_r = 1.5 + 7.5 = 9\ m^3/s\\ BOD_5^{mix} &= \frac{Q_sB_s+Q_rB_r}{Q_s+Q_r} = \frac{1.5\times 280 + 7.5\times 1.2}{9} = 47.67\ \text{mg/l}\\ DO_{mix} &= \frac{Q_s DO_s+Q_r DO_r}{Q_s+Q_r} = \frac{1.5\times 0.2 + 7.5\times 8.586}{9} = 7.19\ \text{mg/l}\\ D_0 &= DO_{sat}-DO_{mix} = 9.17 - 7.19 = 1.98\ \text{mg/l} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Ultimate BOD and self-purification constant

L0=BOD51−10−5K=47.671−10−5×0.1=69.71 mg/lf=RK=0.50.1=5.00\begin{aligned} L_0 &= \frac{BOD_5}{1-10^{-5K}} = \frac{47.67}{1-10^{-5\times 0.1}} = 69.71\ \text{mg/l}\\ f &= \frac{R}{K} = \frac{0.5}{0.1} = 5.00 \end{aligned}

Step 3: Critical time and critical deficit

tc=1K(f−1)log⁡10[f{1−(f−1)D0L0}]=10.1(5.00−1)log⁡10[5.00{1−(5.00−1)1.9869.71}]=1.616 daysDc=L0f 10−Ktc=69.715.00×10−0.1×1.616=9.61 mg/l\begin{aligned} t_c &= \frac{1}{K(f-1)}\log_{10}\left[f\left\{1-(f-1)\frac{D_0}{L_0}\right\}\right]\\ &= \frac{1}{0.1(5.00-1)}\log_{10}\left[5.00\left\{1-(5.00-1)\frac{1.98}{69.71}\right\}\right] = 1.616\ \text{days}\\ D_c &= \frac{L_0}{f}\,10^{-K t_c} = \frac{69.71}{5.00}\times 10^{-0.1\times 1.616} = 9.61\ \text{mg/l} \end{aligned}

(a) Critical DO deficit

Dc=9.61D_c = 9.61 mg/l (minimum DO =9.17−9.61=−0.44=9.17-9.61=-0.44 mg/l).

(b) Location of the critical deficit

xc=v tc=0.8×86400×1.616/1000=111.72 km downstreamx_c = v\,t_c = 0.8\times 86400\times 1.616/1000 = 111.72\ \text{km downstream}

(c) BOD5 of a sample taken at the critical point

BOD remaining at time tct_c is Lt=L0 10−Ktc=69.71×10−0.1×1.616=48.05L_t = L_0\,10^{-Kt_c} = 69.71\times 10^{-0.1\times 1.616} = 48.05 mg/l (ultimate). The 5-day BOD of that sample is

BOD5=Lt(1−10−5K)=48.05×0.6838=32.85 mg/lBOD_5 = L_t\left(1-10^{-5K}\right) = 48.05\times 0.6838 = 32.85\ \text{mg/l}

(d) Sag curve

Deficit at time tt: Dt=KL0R−K(10−Kt−10−Rt)+D0 10−RtD_t=\dfrac{K L_0}{R-K}\left(10^{-Kt}-10^{-Rt}\right)+D_0\,10^{-Rt}, and DOt=9.17−DtDO_t = 9.17-D_t.

t (days)Deficit DtD_t (mg/l)DO (mg/l)
01.987.19
0.56.852.32
18.960.21
1.59.59-0.42
29.45-0.28
2.58.930.24
38.250.92
46.782.39
55.463.71
64.364.81
82.766.41
101.747.43
 7.43 |*                                   * * *  *
 6.45 |                              * * *         
 5.47 |                         * *                
 4.48 |                     * *                    
 3.50 |                   *                        
 2.52 |  *            * *                          
 1.54 |            *                               
 0.56 |    *   * *                                 
-0.42 |      *                                     
      +--------------------------------------------
       0                                10  t, days

The DO falls from 7.19 mg/l to a minimum of -0.44 mg/l at tc=1.616t_c=1.616 days (the critical point), then recovers towards 9.17 mg/l as reaeration exceeds deoxygenation. Negative DO values only mean that the oxygen is exhausted (the stream turns anaerobic in that stretch); this effluent needs treatment.

Answer: Dc=9.61D_c=9.61 mg/l; xc=111.72x_c=111.72 km; BOD5 at critical point =32.85=32.85 mg/l.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Sanitary Engineering chapter 6 questions →