Skip to main content

Mixing three gravel quarries to specification

Short answer

Using control sieves, a trial proportion of Quarry A 10%, Quarry B 25%, Quarry C 65% is taken. The blend yields 100, 96.8, 70.8, 45.8, 31.2, 17.9, and 6.7% passing on the specified sieves, all within specification limits.

The table below gives the sieve analysis results of three gravel quarries under investigation. Calculate the mixing properties to meet the given gradation specification.

Sieve size (mm)Quarry A (% passing)Quarry B (% passing)Quarry C (% passing)Specification
25.4100100100100
12.71001009590-100
4.761001005560-75
1.18100653040-55
0.30100252320-35
0.157518912-22
0.07540335-10

Aim: find the proportions aa, bb, cc (in %) of quarries A, B and C, with a+b+c=100a + b + c = 100, so that the combined % passing at every sieve falls within the specification. The mix passing at a sieve is

Pmix=a PA+b PB+c PC100P_{mix} = \frac{a\,P_A + b\,P_B + c\,P_C}{100}

Assumption: the "Specification" column gives the allowable range of % passing; the target is near the middle of each range.

Step 1: Decide the main fraction by control sieves

  • Quarry A is a fine material (100% passes even 0.30 mm, and 40% passes 0.075 mm). Quarry B is a sand (all of it passes 4.76 mm, with few fines). Quarry C is the coarsest (gravel).
  • 4.76 mm sieve: only C has coarse material (55% passing), so P=100−45 c/100P = 100 - 45\,c/100. The range 60-75 gives c=55.6c = 55.6 to 88.9%88.9\%, so C is the main component (about 65%).
  • 0.075 mm sieve: P=[40a+3(b+c)]/100=3+0.37aP = [40a + 3(b + c)]/100 = 3 + 0.37a (since b+c=100−ab + c = 100 - a). For 5 to 10, a=5.4a = 5.4 to 18.9%18.9\%, so A is a small proportion (about 10%).
  • The remainder is B: b=100−a−cb = 100 - a - c.

Step 2: Trial mix A : B : C = 10 : 25 : 65

Sieve (mm)A x 0.10B x 0.25C x 0.65Mix % passingSpecOK
25.410.0025.0065.00100.0100yes
12.710.0025.0061.7596.890-100yes
4.7610.0025.0035.7570.860-75yes
1.1810.0016.2519.5045.840-55yes
0.3010.006.2514.9531.220-35yes
0.157.504.505.8517.912-22yes
0.0754.000.751.956.75-10yes

All sieves are inside the specification. (A check of all combinations in 1% steps gives the feasible range as A 6-15%, B 0-38%, C 56-85%; the least-squares fit to the mid-points is about 8 : 25 : 67, which is also acceptable. The trial mix 10 : 25 : 65 is rounded and convenient for site batching.)

Answer: Quarry A : Quarry B : Quarry C = 10% : 25% : 65%, giving a blend passing 100, 96.8, 70.8, 45.8, 31.2, 17.9 and 6.7% on the 25.4, 12.7, 4.76, 1.18, 0.30, 0.15 and 0.075 mm sieves.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transportation Engineering I chapter 6 questions →