Skip to main content

Gravity dam section: shear stress near toe (2082)

Short answer

Using force/moment equilibrium with uplift, FS overturning=2.24, sliding=1.64, SFF=9.1, resultant inside middle third; toe/heel stresses 976 and 314 kN/m2, both below 2500, shear stresses 570.2 (toe) and 214.4 kN/m2 (heel), below 2200, so dam is stable.

The figure below (all dimensions are in m) shows the section of a concrete gravity dam. Neglecting the effects of earthquakes, check the stability of the dam. Also, calculate the intensity of the shear stresses on a horizontal plane near toe and heel. Assume the unit weight of concrete is 24 kN/m³. The allowable stress and average shear strength in the concrete may be taken as 2500 kN/m² and 2200 kN/m², respectively. Take μ = 0.75. [Figure: crest width 10.0 m; 5.0 m from the top to the water level; upstream face vertical for 40.0 m of water depth below the 5.0 m, then flared for the lower 20.0 m with a horizontal run of 15.0 m to the heel; downstream face vertical for the top 10.0 m, then sloping to the toe with a horizontal run of 35.0 m; tail water depth 8.0 m; a drainage gallery in the body of the dam (5.0 m dimension marked below the gallery).]

Assumptions (from the figure description)

  • Dam height =5+40+20=65=5+40+20=65 m. Crest width 10 m. U/s face vertical down to 20 m above the base, then flared with a horizontal run of 15 m to the heel. Water level 5 m below the crest, so Hw=60H_w=60 m. D/s face vertical for the top 10 m, then sloping (35 m horizontal run over 55 m height) to the toe. Base width B=15+10+35=60B=15+10+35=60 m.
  • Tail water depth Ht=8H_t=8 m. γc=24\gamma_c=24 kN/m³, γw=10\gamma_w=10 kN/m³, μ=0.75\mu=0.75.
  • Uplift: full hydrostatic head at the heel (γwHw=600\gamma_wH_w=600 kN/m²) and at the toe (γwHt=80\gamma_wH_t=80 kN/m²). The drainage gallery (assumed with its centre 5 m from the heel) reduces the uplift at the gallery to 80+13(600−80)=253.380+\frac13(600-80)=253.3 kN/m². Earthquake is neglected.
 crest 10 m
  +--------+
 ~|~~5 m~~~|  water level
  |        |  d/s vertical 10 m
  |  40 m  \
  |         \  slope: 35 m run in 55 m
  |  20 m    \
   \__________\_ tail water 8 m
  15     10     35   B = 60 m

Forces and moments about the toe

ForceMagnitude (kN/m)Arm from toe (m)Moment about toe (kN·m/m)
Vertical (resisting)
Flare triangle (15 × 20)3,600.050.00180,000
Rectangle 10 × 6515,600.040.00624,000
D/s triangle (35 × 55)23,100.023.33539,000
Water on u/s face7,500.053.00397,500
Tail water on d/s face203.61.70346
ΣW (downward)50,003.6ΣM_R = 1,740,846
Horizontal / uplift (overturning)
Water thrust Pw=12γwHw2P_w=\frac12\gamma_w H_w^218,000.020.00360,000
Uplift part 1 (upward)1,266.757.5072,833
Uplift part 2 (upward)866.758.3350,556
Uplift part 3 (upward)4,400.027.50121,000
Uplift part 4 (upward)4,766.736.67174,778
Uplift U11,300.0
Tail water thrust (resisting)320.02.67853
Total overturningΣM_O = 779,167

(The tail water also acts on the sloping d/s face; its vertical component is included as a resisting load, and its horizontal thrust acts at Ht/3H_t/3 above the base.)

Stability

  • ΣV=50,003.6−11,300.0=38,703.6\Sigma V=50,003.6-11,300.0=38,703.6 kN/m; ΣH=18,000.0−320.0=17,680.0\Sigma H=18,000.0-320.0=17,680.0 kN/m
  • ΣMR=1,741,699\Sigma M_R=1,741,699 kN·m/m (including tail water); ΣMO=779,167\Sigma M_O=779,167 kN·m/m

Overturning: FSo=1,741,699/779,167=2.24FS_o=1,741,699/779,167=2.24 — safe (> 1.5).

Sliding (friction only): FSs=μΣV/ΣH=0.75×38,703.6/17,680.0=1.64FS_s=\mu\Sigma V/\Sigma H = 0.75\times38,703.6/17,680.0=1.64 — safe (> 1).

Shear-friction factor: SFF=μΣV+τBΣH=0.75×38,703.6+2200×6017,680.0=9.1SFF=\dfrac{\mu\Sigma V+\tau B}{\Sigma H}=\dfrac{0.75\times38,703.6+2200\times60}{17,680.0}=9.1 — very safe (> 3 to 5).

Resultant and stresses: xˉ=962,532/38,703.6=24.87\bar x=962,532/38,703.6=24.87 m from the toe; e=30−24.87=5.13e=30-24.87=5.13 m; B/6=10B/6=10 m (inside the middle third).

σtoe=645.1 (1+0.513)=976.0 kN/m2,σheel=645.1 (1−0.513)=314.1 kN/m2\sigma_{toe}=645.1\,(1+0.513)=976.0\ \text{kN/m}^2,\quad \sigma_{heel}=645.1\,(1-0.513)=314.1\ \text{kN/m}^2

Both are compressive and below the allowable 2500 kN/m².

Shear stress on a horizontal plane near the toe and heel

Face slopes: d/s tan⁡ϕd=35/55=0.636\tan\phi_d=35/55=0.636; u/s (flare) tan⁡ϕu=15/20=0.75\tan\phi_u=15/20=0.75. Water pressures at the faces: p′=γwHt=80p'=\gamma_wH_t=80 kN/m² at the toe and p=γwHw=600p=\gamma_wH_w=600 kN/m² at the heel.

τtoe=(σtoe−p′)tan⁡ϕd=(976.0−80)×0.636=570.2 kN/m2\tau_{toe}=(\sigma_{toe}-p')\tan\phi_d=(976.0-80)\times0.636=570.2\ \text{kN/m}^2 τheel=(p−σheel)tan⁡ϕu=(600−314.1)×0.75=214.4 kN/m2\tau_{heel}=(p-\sigma_{heel})\tan\phi_u=(600-314.1)\times0.75=214.4\ \text{kN/m}^2

Both are much smaller than the average shear strength of 2200 kN/m². Principal stresses: σ1,toe=σtoesec⁡2ϕd−p′tan⁡2ϕd=1338.9\sigma_{1,toe}=\sigma_{toe}\sec^2\phi_d-p'\tan^2\phi_d=1338.9 kN/m², σ1,heel=σheelsec⁡2ϕu−ptan⁡2ϕu=153.3\sigma_{1,heel}=\sigma_{heel}\sec^2\phi_u-p\tan^2\phi_u=153.3 kN/m².

Conclusion: the dam is safe against overturning (2.24), sliding (1.64; shear-friction factor 9.1), tension (none: the minimum stress of 314 kN/m² is compressive) and crushing (maximum principal stress 1339 kN/m² < 2500 kN/m²).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Hydropower Engineering chapter 4 questions →