- 2080 Bhadra · 10 marks
LPF prototype conversion and second order HPF
Short answer
A low-pass prototype is a normalized LC ladder with values from Butterworth or Chebyshev polynomials. For a high-pass filter, series inductors become series capacitors and shunt capacitors become shunt inductors. A second-order microstrip π-section HPF uses a series gap capacitor (1.125 pF) and a short-circuited stub inductor (2.813 nH).
How is a low pass filter prototyped based on Butterworth or Chebyshev approximations and converted into other types of filters? Implement a second order high pass filter π-section using microstrips.
Low-pass prototype (Butterworth / Chebyshev)
A low-pass prototype is a normalised LC ladder with source resistance g₀ = 1 Ω and cut-off ωc = 1 rad/s. Its element values g₁…g_N are chosen so that its power loss ratio follows the chosen approximation.
g0=1 g2 (L) g4 (L)
-/\/\-+--UUU--+--UUU--+-- g(N+1)
| | | (load)
g1 (C) g3 (C) ...
| | |
------+-------+--------+--
| Approximation | Power loss ratio | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Butterworth | 1 + k²(ω/ωc)²ᴺ | Maximally flat, slower roll-off |
| Chebyshev | 1 + k²T_N²(ω/ωc) | Equal ripple, sharper roll-off |
- Butterworth: g_k = 2 sin[(2k − 1)π/(2N)], with k = 1 (3 dB at ωc). For N = 3: 1, 2, 1.
- Chebyshev: g-values depend on the ripple and are taken from tables. For 0.5 dB ripple, N = 3: 1.5963, 1.0967, 1.5963, with g₄ = 1.0.
- The order N is found from attenuation-versus-|ω/ωc| − 1 charts for the required stop-band attenuation.
Conversion to real values and other filter types
Impedance scaling: L' = R₀L, C' = C/R₀, R' = R₀.
Frequency scaling and transformations (ω₀ = √(ω₁ω₂), Δ = (ω₂ − ω₁)/ω₀):
| Prototype element | Low-pass | High-pass | Band-pass | Band-stop |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Series L_k | L = R₀g/ωc | series C = 1/(R₀ωc g) | series LC | parallel LC (in series) |
| Shunt C_k | C = g/(R₀ωc) | shunt L = R₀/(ωc g) | parallel LC | series LC (shunt) |
- LP → HP: ω → −ωc/ω, so inductors become capacitors and capacitors become inductors.
- LP → BP: ω → (1/Δ)(ω/ω₀ − ω₀/ω). A series L becomes a series LC (L' = R₀g/(ω₀Δ), C' = Δ/(ω₀R₀g)). A shunt C becomes a parallel LC.
- LP → BS: the inverse of the BP transformation.
The lumped elements are then realised with transmission lines using Richards' transformation and Kuroda identities, or stepped-impedance sections.
Second-order high-pass π-section in microstrip
Assumed: fc = 2 GHz, R₀ = 50 Ω, so ωc = 1.2566×10¹⁰ rad/s. A π-section has a shunt L, a series C and a second shunt L. A strictly second-order filter has only two reactive elements, so the second shunt arm is left out (half-π). A full symmetric π with both shunt arms is third order. Both sets of values are given:
2nd order (Butterworth N = 2, g1 = g2 = 1.4142):
shunt L1 = R0 / (ωc g1) = 50 / (1.2566e10 × 1.4142)
= 2.813 nH
series C2 = 1 / (R0 ωc g2) = 1 / (50 × 1.2566e10 × 1.4142)
= 1.125 pF
Full π (Butterworth N = 3, g = 1, 2, 1):
L1 = L3 = R0 / ωc = 3.979 nH, C2 = 1 / (2 R0 ωc) = 0.796 pF
| Design | Shunt L1 | Series C2 | Shunt L3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strict 2nd order (N = 2) | 2.813 nH | 1.125 pF | omitted |
| Full symmetric π (N = 3) | 3.979 nH | 0.796 pF | 3.979 nH |
Lumped: o----+---| |---+----o
| C2 |
L1 L3 (L3 omitted for N = 2)
| |
o----+---------+----o
Microstrip (top view):
50 Ω ======+====| |====+====== 50 Ω
| gap or |
short inter- short
stub digital stub
(L1) C2 (L3)
| |
[via] [via] -> ground
- Series C2: a gap or interdigital capacitor in the main line (1.125 pF for N = 2, or 0.796 pF for the full π).
- Shunt L1 (and L3): a short-circuited stub ending in a via. By Richards' transformation, a λ/8 shorted stub at fc with Z₀ = ωcL gives the required reactance: Z₀ = 50/1.4142 = 35.4 Ω for N = 2, or Z₀ = 50 Ω for the full π. Alternatively, a shorter high-impedance stub can be used, for example Z₀ = 100 Ω with tan βl = 0.354 (βl ≈ 19.5°) for the 2.813 nH inductor.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Butterworth/Chebyshev LPF and double π-section · RF and Microwave Engineering, chapter 6
- Butterworth LPF prototype and π-section microstrip · RF and Microwave Engineering, chapter 6
- S-parameters and Butterworth/Chebyshev filter responses · RF and Microwave Engineering, chapter 3
- Filter design steps and microstrip HPF · RF and Microwave Engineering, chapter 6
- 3rd order Butterworth HPF from LPF transfer function · Filter Design, chapter 5
- RC low and high pass filters · Basic Electronics Engineering, chapter 1
- Ideal low pass and high pass filters · Signals and Systems, chapter 5
- All-pass filters in delay equalization; 3rd order Bessel-Thomson · Filter Design, chapter 2 · asked 3×