Skip to main content

Generator choice and significance of SCR

Short answer

Factors: MVA/pf, voltage, speed/poles, shaft, reactances/SCR, inertia, efficiency, insulation class, cooling, excitation, NGT, grid requirements, transport. SCR ≈ 1/Xd sets stability: higher SCR gives larger Pmax, better voltage regulation, prevents self-excitation on long lines but increases machine size and fault level. Typical hydro SCR 1.0–1.2.

Discuss the various factors which should be considered for the choice of generator during the design of a power plant. Also mention the significance of short circuit ratio in the selection of generator.

Factors for the choice of generator

  1. Rating (MVA) and power factor: S=Pturbine ηg/cos⁡ϕS = P_{turbine}\,\eta_g / \cos\phi; power factor usually 0.85–0.9 lagging so the unit can supply reactive power. Some overload margin (e.g. 10%) is often specified.
  2. Rated voltage: usually 6.6 kV or 11 kV for hydro units (higher, e.g. 13.8–15.75 kV, for very large units); chosen with GSU and bus/cable cost.
  3. Speed and number of poles: fixed by the turbine: N=120f/pN = 120f/p. Hydro units are slow, salient-pole machines with many poles.
  4. Shaft arrangement: vertical (large Francis/Kaplan) or horizontal (small Pelton/Francis).
  5. Reactances and SCR: Xd′′X''_d sets fault level and breaker rating; SCR and XdX_d set stability and voltage regulation.
  6. Inertia constant (GD²): larger inertia limits speed rise on load rejection and improves stability, but costs more.
  7. Efficiency and losses: high efficiency (above 97–98%) saves energy over the plant life.
  8. Insulation and temperature rise: class F insulation with class B temperature rise is common; altitude derating above 1000 m.
  9. Cooling: air-cooled (open or closed with air–water coolers) for hydro.
  10. Excitation system: brushless for small/medium units, static for large units.
  11. Neutral grounding: high-resistance grounding via NGT.
  12. Grid requirements: capability curve, reactive power range, fault ride-through, harmonics.
  13. Transport and erection limits: weight and size on hill roads; split stator if needed.
  14. Standards and cost: IEC 60034; capital cost versus loss capitalisation.

Significance of SCR in generator selection

SCR≈1/XdSCR \approx 1/X_d (p.u.). It is specified in the purchase specification because:

  • Stability: steady-state limit Pmax=EV (SCR)P_{max} = EV\,(SCR); higher SCR gives a larger stability margin, important for plants connected to the grid through long lines.
  • Voltage regulation: higher SCR gives less voltage change with load.
  • Line charging: high SCR prevents self-excitation when charging long, unloaded lines.
  • Cost and size: higher SCR needs a larger air gap and more field copper, making the machine heavier and costlier.
  • Fault level: higher SCR raises short-circuit current and switchgear rating. Typical selection: hydro units about 1.0–1.2 (salient pole), turbo units 0.5–0.7.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Power Plant Design chapter 4 questions →