Skip to main content

Lead compensator for 4/[s(s+2)], ts=2 s

Short answer

A lead compensator designed via root locus method gives Gc(s) = 4.73 (s+2.93)/(s+5.46). The dominant closed-loop poles become -2 ± j3.464, achieving settling time 2 s with unchanged damping ratio 0.5 and approximately the same 16.3% overshoot.

For a unity feedback system with open loop transfer function G(s) = 4/[s(s+2)], design a Lead compensator such that settling time would become 2 seconds without change in maximum overshoot of the system.

The specification is in the time domain, so the lead compensator is designed by the root-locus method.

Step 1: Present system

C(s)R(s)=4s2+2s+4⇒ωn=2 rad/s, ζ=22×2=0.5\frac{C(s)}{R(s)}=\frac{4}{s^2+2s+4}\Rightarrow\omega_n=2\ \text{rad/s},\ \zeta=\frac{2}{2\times2}=0.5 ts=4ζωn=41=4 s (2% criterion),Mp=e−πζ/1−ζ2=16.3%t_s=\frac{4}{\zeta\omega_n}=\frac{4}{1}=4\ \text{s (2\% criterion)},\qquad M_p=e^{-\pi\zeta/\sqrt{1-\zeta^2}}=16.3\%

Step 2: Desired poles

Same overshoot means same ζ=0.5\zeta=0.5. New settling time 2 s:

ζωn=42=2⇒ωn=4 rad/s,ωd=41−0.25=3.464\zeta\omega_n=\frac{4}{2}=2\Rightarrow\omega_n=4\ \text{rad/s},\quad\omega_d=4\sqrt{1-0.25}=3.464 sd=−2±j3.464s_d=-2\pm j3.464

Step 3: Angle deficiency

∠sd=180∘−tan⁡−13.4642=120∘∠(sd+2)=90∘∠G(sd)=−(120∘+90∘)=−210∘ϕ=−180∘−(−210∘)=30∘\begin{aligned} \angle s_d&=180^\circ-\tan^{-1}\frac{3.464}{2}=120^\circ\\ \angle(s_d+2)&=90^\circ\\ \angle G(s_d)&=-(120^\circ+90^\circ)=-210^\circ\\ \phi&=-180^\circ-(-210^\circ)=30^\circ \end{aligned}

Step 4: Pole and zero by the bisector method

  1. Draw a horizontal line PA from P=sdP=s_d to the left, and line PO to the origin. Angle APO =180∘−60∘=120∘=180^\circ-60^\circ=120^\circ.
  2. Bisect it: the bisector PB makes 60∘60^\circ with PA (direction 240∘240^\circ).
  3. Draw PC and PD at ±ϕ/2=±15∘\pm\phi/2=\pm15^\circ from PB; they meet the real axis at the zero and pole.
zero: z=−2−3.464tan⁡75∘=−2−0.928=−2.93pole: p=−2−3.464tan⁡45∘=−2−3.464=−5.46\begin{aligned} \text{zero: }z&=-2-\frac{3.464}{\tan75^\circ}=-2-0.928=-2.93\\ \text{pole: }p&=-2-\frac{3.464}{\tan45^\circ}=-2-3.464=-5.46 \end{aligned}

Check: ∠(sd+2.93)=75∘\angle(s_d+2.93)=75^\circ, ∠(sd+5.46)=45∘\angle(s_d+5.46)=45^\circ, net lead =30∘=30^\circ ✓.

Step 5: Gain (magnitude condition)

Kc=∣sd∣ ∣sd+2∣ ∣sd+5.46∣4 ∣sd+2.93∣=4×3.464×4.8994×3.586=4.73K_c=\frac{|s_d|\,|s_d+2|\,|s_d+5.46|}{4\,|s_d+2.93|}=\frac{4\times3.464\times4.899}{4\times3.586}=4.73 Gc(s)=4.73 s+2.93s+5.46G_c(s)=4.73\,\frac{s+2.93}{s+5.46}

Step 6: Compensated system

Gc(s)G(s)=18.93(s+2.93)s(s+2)(s+5.46)G_c(s)G(s)=\frac{18.93(s+2.93)}{s(s+2)(s+5.46)}

Closed-loop poles: −2±j3.464-2\pm j3.464 (desired) and a third pole at −3.46-3.46, which lies close to the zero at −2.93-2.93, so its effect is small and the response is dominated by the desired pair.

          jw
    sd x  | j3.46
       \  |
 --x---o--x---x--- sigma
 -5.46 -2.93 -2  0
ItemBeforeAfter
ζ\zeta0.50.5
ωn\omega_n2 rad/s4 rad/s
tst_s4 s2 s
MpM_p16.3%≈16.3%
KvK_v25.07

Alternative: placing the zero at −2-2 (cancelling the plant pole) needs a pole at −4-4 and gives Gc=4s+2s+4G_c=4\frac{s+2}{s+4} with closed loop exactly 16s2+4s+16\frac{16}{s^2+4s+16}.

Answer: Gc(s)=4.73 s+2.93s+5.46G_c(s)=4.73\,\dfrac{s+2.93}{s+5.46}; dominant poles at −2 ± j3.46 give ts = 2 s with the same ζ = 0.5 (Mp ≈ 16%).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 7 questions →