Skip to main content

Stability: H 49/249, F 56/243, three joints

Short answer

Using phi=25°, stereonet checks find no plane or toppling failure; however, wedge failure along J2-J3 intersection is possible (plunge 27.7° towards 200°, between friction angle and face apparent dip 36.9°). Slope needs bolting or flattening to below 39° to prevent wedge sliding.

Discuss the stability analysis of the given planes. H = 49/249, F = 56/243, J1 = 58/071, J2 = 30/175, J3 = 83/286 and ϕ = 25°. [Figure: stereonet showing H, F, J1, J2, J3 and the friction circle]

Method (lower-hemisphere stereonet, equal-angle): plot the great circle of the slope face and of each discontinuity, draw the friction circle of radius ϕ\phi, and mark intersections of great circles. Then apply the kinematic tests below.

Data (dip/dip direction)

H (hill slope) 49/249; F 56/243; J1 58/071; J2 30/175; J3 83/286; ϕ=25∘\phi = 25^\circ.

Single planes

Plane (dip/dip dir)Diff. of dip dir from slopeDaylights (ψp<ψf\psi_p<\psi_f)ψp>ϕ\psi_p>\phiResult
F (56/243)6°noyesSafe (does not daylight)
J1 (58/071)178°noyesSafe
J2 (30/175)74°yesyesSafe
J3 (83/286)37°noyesSafe

Intersections

PairIntersection plunge/trendFace apparent dip along trendResult
F x J230.0° / 176°18.5°Safe (does not daylight)
F x J349.1° / 204°39.2°Safe (does not daylight)
J2 x J327.7° / 200°36.9°Wedge failure

(The other 3 intersections plunge into the hill, away from the face, and cannot slide.)

Result

  • F has almost the same dip direction as the slope but is steeper (56∘>49∘56^\circ > 49^\circ), so it does not daylight: no plane failure.
  • J1 dips into the hill (071, against 249 - 180 = 069). The toppling limit is 90∘−49∘+25∘=66∘90^\circ - 49^\circ + 25^\circ = 66^\circ, but ψ=58∘<66∘\psi = 58^\circ < 66^\circ, so toppling is not expected.
  • J3 is very steep, and J2 is gentle and dips almost at right angles to the face direction: neither slides alone.
  • The intersection J2 x J3 plunges 27.7∘27.7^\circ towards 200∘200^\circ. This is greater than ϕ=25∘\phi = 25^\circ and smaller than the apparent dip of the face in that direction (36.9∘36.9^\circ), so it plots between the friction circle and the slope great circle.

Conclusion: the slope is stable against plane and toppling failure, but wedge failure along the intersection of J2 and J3 is possible. It can be treated by bolting, or by flattening the face to below about 39∘39^\circ, so that the apparent dip of the face towards 200° becomes less than the 27.7∘27.7^\circ plunge of the wedge (tan⁡ψcos⁡49.7∘=tan⁡27.7∘⇒ψ≈39∘\tan\psi\cos 49.7^\circ = \tan 27.7^\circ \Rightarrow \psi \approx 39^\circ).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Engineering Geology II chapter 6 questions →