- 2079 Chaitra · 5 marks
GMR of stranded vs solid conductor
Short answer
For a 7-strand conductor with strand radius r, overall radius is 3r. Stranded GMR = 2.1767r, solid GMR of same diameter = 0.7788*3r = 2.3364r. The stranded GMR is about 7% lower due to air gaps reducing effective conducting cross-section, increasing inductance compared to a solid conductor.
With a suitable example show that the geometric mean radius of a stranded conductor is lower than that of a solid conductor of the same overall diameter.
The geometric mean radius (GMR) of a conductor is the radius of a fictitious thin tube that has the same internal plus external flux linkage as the real conductor. For a solid round conductor of radius , . A stranded conductor of the same overall diameter contains air gaps between strands, so its current is spread over less metal and its effective GMR is smaller.
Example: 7-strand conductor
Take a 7-strand conductor, each strand of radius : one central strand and six touching strands around it. Overall radius .
(2) (3)
(7) (1) (4) 1 = centre strand
(6) (5) ring radius = 2r
Distances between strand centres:
| Pair type | Distance | Ordered pairs |
|---|---|---|
| Centre to outer | 12 | |
| Adjacent outers | 12 | |
| Outer to next-but-one | 12 | |
| Outer to opposite | 6 | |
| Self () | 7 |
With strands there are terms:
Solid conductor of the same overall diameter
Comparison
So the 7-strand conductor has a GMR about 7% smaller than a solid conductor of the same diameter.
Why: the GMR depends on the actual cross-section that carries current. Stranding leaves air gaps, so the current-carrying material sits in a smaller effective area. A smaller GMR means the stranded conductor has a slightly higher inductance () than a solid conductor of the same outer diameter.
Answer: (stranded) < (solid).
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- GMR of 6-strand triangular conductor · Power System Analysis I, chapter 4 · asked 2×
- GMR of 5-strand conductor, 0.5 cm strands · Power System Analysis I, chapter 4 · asked 2×
- GMR of 4-strand conductor in terms of r · Power System Analysis I, chapter 4
- Optimum conductor radius for minimum cable stress · Power System Analysis I, chapter 2
- Stranded vs bundled conductors · Power System Analysis I, chapter 2
- GMR for inductance vs capacitance · Power System Analysis I, chapter 4
- Hollow shaft stronger than solid shaft (same weight) · Strength of Materials, chapter 6 · asked 3×
- Solid shaft 120 Nm: diameter from limits · Strength of Materials, chapter 6 · asked 2×
- Torsion vs bending; hollow shaft replaced by solid · Strength of Materials, chapter 6
- Torsional rigidity; hollow shaft vs solid shaft strength · Strength of Materials, chapter 6