Skip to main content

Transposition; single-phase capacitance with earth

Short answer

Transposition ensures equal average inductance and capacitance per phase, preventing unbalanced voltages and reducing interference. For a single-phase line above ground, by method of images the line-to-line capacitance is C_ab = π ε0 / ln(D/(r√(1+D²/(4h²)))) F/m, and phase capacitance to neutral C_n = 2C_ab.

What is the importance of transposition of high voltage transmission lines? Derive the line capacitance and phase capacitance of a single phase line considering the effect of ground.

Importance of transposition

Transposition means exchanging the positions of the phase conductors at regular intervals along the line, so that each phase occupies each position for one-third of the length.

  • With unsymmetrical spacing, the flux linkages and charges of the three phases differ, so the phases have unequal inductance and capacitance.
  • Unequal parameters give unequal voltage drops, so the receiving-end voltages become unbalanced even with balanced load.
  • Transposition makes the average inductance and capacitance of each phase equal, so the line behaves as a balanced circuit and can be modelled per phase using Deq=D12D23D313D_{eq} = \sqrt[3]{D_{12}D_{23}D_{31}}.
  • It reduces electromagnetic and electrostatic interference with nearby telephone and communication lines.

Capacitance of a single-phase line considering ground

Let conductors a and b (radius rr, spacing DD) be at height hh above ground, carrying charges +q+q and −q-q per metre. By the method of images, the earth is replaced by image conductors a' (−q-q) and b' (+q+q) at depth hh.

   +q a o------- D -------o b -q
        |                 |
        h                 h
 ===============================  ground
        h                 h
        |                 |
   -q a'o                 o b' +q
   a-a' = 2h,  a-b' = sqrt(4h^2 + D^2)

Voltage between a and b due to all four charges, using Vab=12πε0∑qkln⁡DkbDkaV_{ab} = \dfrac{1}{2\pi\varepsilon_0}\sum q_k\ln\dfrac{D_{kb}}{D_{ka}}:

Vab=12πε0[qln⁡Dr−qln⁡rD−qln⁡4h2+D22h+qln⁡2h4h2+D2]=qπε0[ln⁡Dr−ln⁡4h2+D22h]=qπε0ln⁡Dr1+D2/4h2\begin{aligned} V_{ab} &= \frac{1}{2\pi\varepsilon_0}\left[q\ln\frac{D}{r} - q\ln\frac{r}{D} - q\ln\frac{\sqrt{4h^2+D^2}}{2h} + q\ln\frac{2h}{\sqrt{4h^2+D^2}}\right] \\ &= \frac{q}{\pi\varepsilon_0}\left[\ln\frac{D}{r} - \ln\frac{\sqrt{4h^2+D^2}}{2h}\right] \\ &= \frac{q}{\pi\varepsilon_0}\ln\frac{D}{r\sqrt{1+D^2/4h^2}} \end{aligned}

Line capacitance (between conductors):

Cab=qVab=πε0ln⁡(Dr1+D2/4h2) F/mC_{ab} = \frac{q}{V_{ab}} = \frac{\pi\varepsilon_0}{\ln\left(\dfrac{D}{r\sqrt{1+D^2/4h^2}}\right)}\ \text{F/m}

Phase capacitance (each conductor to neutral, Van=Vab/2V_{an} = V_{ab}/2):

Cn=2Cab=2πε0ln⁡(Dr1+D2/4h2) F/mC_n = 2C_{ab} = \frac{2\pi\varepsilon_0}{\ln\left(\dfrac{D}{r\sqrt{1+D^2/4h^2}}\right)}\ \text{F/m}

Since 1+D2/4h2>1\sqrt{1+D^2/4h^2} > 1, the ground increases the capacitance. When h≫Dh \gg D, the term tends to 1 and the result reduces to the usual Cab=πε0/ln⁡(D/r)C_{ab} = \pi\varepsilon_0/\ln(D/r).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Power System Analysis I chapter 4 questions →