Skip to main content

Double mass curve, station X and 25 stations, 1941-1976

Short answer

A double mass curve reveals inconsistency with a regime change after 1952. Unadjusted mean is 109.8 cm; adjusted to the present regime it is 97.2 cm. The 1941–1952 data are corrected by a factor of 0.726.

The annual rainfall at station X and the average of annual rainfall at 25 surrounding base stations in cm are given below for the period of 36 years starting from 1941.

i) Check whether the data of station X is consistent. ii) In which year a change in regime is indicated? iii) Compute the mean annual rainfall for station X at its present site for the given 36 year period, first without adjustment and secondly with the data adjusted for the change in regime. iv) Compute the adjusted annual rainfall at station X for the affected period.

YearRainfall at XAverage rainfall of base stations
1941163135
1942119111
1943121124
1944129111
1945126123
194612090
1947153138
1948172119
1949127108
1950108107
1951126111
1952190142
1953112112
195497 [?]99
19558693
1956111131
19576892
195888142
1959112123
196095142
196110692
19628191
1963116131
1964112104
19658097
196688111
196785114
19689092
1969120146
19707293
1971113138
197282112
1973116117
1974122152
19757390
197674104

The double mass curve plots cumulative X against cumulative base-station average. A single straight line means consistent data.

(i) Cumulative values and consistency

YearXBase avgCum. baseCum. X
1941163135135163
1942119111246282
1943121124370403
1944129111481532
1945126123604658
194612090694778
1947153138832931
19481721199511103
194912710810591230
195010810711661338
195112611112771464
195219014214191654
195311211215311766
1954979916301863
1955869317231949
195611113118542060
1957689219462128
19588814220882216
195911212322112328
19609514223532423
19611069224452529
1962819125362610
196311613126672726
196411210427712838
1965809728682918
19668811129793006
19678511430933091
1968909231853181
196912014633313301
1970729334243373
197111313835623486
19728211236743568
197311611737913684
197412215239433806
1975739040333879
19767410441373953

Plotting cum. X against cum. base average shows a straight line up to 1952 and a flatter straight line afterwards.

  • Slope up to 1952: Ma=16541419=1.1656M_a = \dfrac{1654}{1419} = 1.1656
  • Slope after 1952: Mc=22992718=0.8458M_c = \dfrac{2299}{2718} = 0.8458

The slope changes, so the data of station X are not consistent.

(ii) Change in regime

The break occurs at the 1952 point, so the regime changed after 1952 (the changed conditions apply from 1953). (The 1954 value of 97 is taken as printed.)

(iii) Mean annual rainfall of X (36 years)

  • Without adjustment: Pˉ=395336=109.8\bar P = \dfrac{3953}{36} = 109.8 cm
  • With adjustment to the present site (recent regime), the 1941-1952 data are corrected by Mc/Ma=0.8458/1.1656=0.7257M_c/M_a = 0.8458/1.1656 = 0.7257. Corrected total for 1941-52 =1200.3= 1200.3 cm; total for 1953-76 =2299= 2299 cm.
Pˉadj=1200.3+229936=97.2 cm\bar P_{adj} = \frac{1200.3 + 2299}{36} = 97.2\ \text{cm}

(iv) Adjusted annual rainfall for the affected period (1941-1952)

Pcx=Px×0.7257P_{cx} = P_x \times 0.7257
YearObserved (cm)Adjusted (cm)
1941163118.3
194211986.4
194312187.8
194412993.6
194512691.4
194612087.1
1947153111.0
1948172124.8
194912792.2
195010878.4
195112691.4
1952190137.9

Answer: Inconsistent; change in regime after 1952; mean = 109.8 cm (unadjusted) and 97.2 cm (adjusted); adjusted values for 1941-52 are listed above (factor 0.726).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Engineering Hydrology chapter 2 questions →