Skip to main content

Moment distribution: frame with SFD, AFD, BMD

Short answer

By moment distribution, the final end moments are M_AB = 0, M_BA = 45.19 kNm, M_BC = -79.20 kNm, M_CB = 85.20 kNm, M_BD = 34.00 kNm, M_DB = 4.40 kNm. Shear, axial force, and bending moment diagrams are drawn from these moments and member loads.

Analyse the frame shown in figure below using the moment distribution method. Also draw shear force, axial force and bending moment diagram. [Figure: beam (A hinged at the left end) with 50 kN and 80 kN loads, 30 kN/m UDL on the right portion, fixed right end; column of 5 m with fixed base carrying 15 kN horizontal at the 3 m level; horizontal dimensions 1 m, 3 m, 1 m, 4 m as marked.]

Assumptions (the figure is only described): the beam A-B-C is horizontal, 9 m long: A is a hinge (x = 0), a 50 kN load acts at 1 m, the column BD (5 m, fixed at D) is attached at B (x = 4 m), an 80 kN load acts at 5 m, the beam is fixed at C (x = 9 m) and a UDL of 30 kN/m acts on the last 4 m (x = 5 m to 9 m). The 15 kN horizontal load acts on the column at 3 m above its base D (2 m below B), pointing to the right. EI is the same for all members. The fixed support at C prevents sway, so the frame is solved without a sway case.

Members

AB = 4 m (50 kN at 1 m from A), BC = 5 m (80 kN at 1 m from B; 30 kN/m from 1 m to 5 m), BD = 5 m (15 kN at 2 m from B). A is a hinge: the member AB is stiffened by 3/4.

Fixed-end moments (clockwise +, kNm)

  • AB: FEMAB=−28.13FEM_{AB}=-28.13, FEMBA=9.37FEM_{BA}=9.37 kNm
  • BC: FEMBC=−102.40FEM_{BC}=-102.40, FEMCB=73.60FEM_{CB}=73.60 kNm
  • BD: FEMBD=10.80FEM_{BD}=10.80, FEMDB=−7.20FEM_{DB}=-7.20 kNm The FEM of AB at B is modified for the hinge at A: FEMBA′=FEMBA−12FEMAB=23.44FEM'_{BA}=FEM_{BA}-\tfrac12FEM_{AB}=23.44 kNm.

Distribution factors at B (k=EI/Lk=EI/L)

  • Joint B: relative stiffness Σk\Sigma k = 0.5875; BA: k=EI/Lk=EI/L = 0.1875 (far end hinged: 3/4 factor), DF = 0.3191; BC: k=EI/Lk=EI/L = 0.2000, DF = 0.3404; BD: k=EI/Lk=EI/L = 0.2000, DF = 0.3404

Moment distribution

BABCCBBDDB
DF0.3190.340-0.340-
FEM23.44-102.4073.6010.80-7.20
Balance21.7523.200.0023.200.00
Carry-over0.000.0011.600.0011.60
Final M45.19-79.2085.2034.004.40

Joint check at B: 45.19+(−79.20)+(34.00)=0.0045.19+(-79.20)+(34.00)=0.00 ✓. Hinge A: MAB=0M_{AB}=0.

Bending moment diagram (sagging/inside tension +, kNm)

MemberBM at first endBM at second endMax within member
AB0.00-45.1926.20 at 1.00 m
BC-79.20-85.2047.41 at 2.02 m
BD34.00-4.40-
Under the 50 kN load: 26.20 kNm; under the 80 kN load: 31.60 kNm.

Shear force and axial force (end values from the member equilibrium)

MemberAxial N (+ tension)Shear at startShear at end
AB9.2726.20-23.80
BC-7.41110.80-89.20
BD-134.60-16.68-1.68

Shear sign: positive when the force on the start end of the member acts along its local y-axis (90° anticlockwise from the direction A to B, B to C, B to D). Axial force: negative = compression. The column pushes joint B to the right with 16.68 kN. With the girder axially rigid, the split of this force between A and C depends on the axial stiffnesses; for equal EAEA it is in inverse proportion to the lengths, so AB takes 16.68×5/9=9.2716.68\times5/9=9.27 kN (tension) and BC takes 16.68×4/9=7.4116.68\times4/9=7.41 kN (compression).

Shear in the girder (kN): AB start 26.20, before the 50 kN load 26.20, after the load -23.80, at B -23.80; BC starts with 110.80, falls to 30.80 after the 80 kN load and decreases linearly under the UDL to -89.20 at C.

Reactions: A: H=−9.27H=-9.27, V=26.20V=26.20, M=0.00M=0.00; C: H=−7.41H=-7.41, V=89.20V=89.20, M=−85.20M=-85.20; D: H=1.68H=1.68, V=134.60V=134.60, M=−4.40M=-4.40.

Answer: MBA=45.19M_{BA}=45.19, MBC=−79.20M_{BC}=-79.20, MCB=85.20M_{CB}=85.20, MBD=34.00M_{BD}=34.00, MDB=4.40M_{DB}=4.40 kNm, MAB=0M_{AB}=0; the SFD, AFD and BMD ordinates are tabulated above.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures II chapter 3 questions →