Skip to main content

Combined sewer, half full, 1.5 m³/s

Short answer

At half full, full discharge is 3.0 m3/s; using Manning's formula gives D=1.907 m, adopt 2.10 m. Dry-season flow ratio gives velocity about 0.77 m/s, so self-cleaning velocity of 0.60 m/s is maintained.

Determine the size of combined circular sewer for a discharge of 1.5 m³/s running half full. Assume a gradient of 1 in 2000 and Manning's rugosity coefficient N = 0.013 (constant for all flows). In the dry season if the flow drops to 0.5 m³/sec, does the flow maintain desired self-cleaning velocity of 0.60 m/sec?

Part 1: Size of the sewer

At half depth (d/D=0.5d/D=0.5) the area and hydraulic radius are half and equal to the full values, respectively: A=Af/2A=A_f/2, R=RfR=R_f, so v=vfv=v_f and, with nn constant, Q=Qf/2Q=Q_f/2.

Qf=2×1.5=3.0 m3/sQ_f=2\times1.5=3.0\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}

Full-pipe Manning's formula: Qf=0.3117nD8/3S1/2Q_f=\dfrac{0.3117}{n}D^{8/3}S^{1/2} with S=12000=0.0005S=\dfrac{1}{2000}=0.0005, n=0.013n=0.013.

D=(Qf n0.3117 S1/2)3/8=(3.0×0.0130.3117×0.02236)3/8=1.907 mD=\left(\frac{Q_f\,n}{0.3117\,S^{1/2}}\right)^{3/8}=\left(\frac{3.0\times0.013}{0.3117\times0.02236}\right)^{3/8}=1.907\ \text{m}

Adopt a standard size D=2.10D=2.10 m. Check: vf=0.3969nD2/3S1/2=1.120v_f=\dfrac{0.3969}{n}D^{2/3}S^{1/2}=1.120 m/s (this is also the velocity at half depth), Qf=3.877Q_f=3.877 m³/s, so half-full capacity =1.939=1.939 m³/s, greater than 1.5 m³/s. Velocity at design flow is above 0.6 m/s.

Part 2: Dry-season flow of 0.5 m³/s

Using the adopted D=2.10D=2.10 m, Qf=3.877Q_f=3.877 m³/s and vf=1.120v_f=1.120 m/s:

QQf=0.53.877=0.1290\frac{Q}{Q_f}=\frac{0.5}{3.877}=0.1290

For circular sections with constant nn, this ratio corresponds to d/D=0.243d/D=0.243 (solving Q/Qf=AAf(RRf)2/3Q/Q_f=\frac{A}{A_f}\left(\frac{R}{R_f}\right)^{2/3}). Then vvf=0.689\dfrac{v}{v_f}=0.689 and

v=0.689×1.120=0.77 m/sv=0.689\times1.120=0.77\ \text{m/s}

Since 0.77 m/s is greater than 0.60 m/s, the flow does maintain the self-cleansing velocity in the dry season.

Answer: D≈2.10D\approx2.10 m (computed 1.907 m). In the dry season the velocity is about 0.77 m/s, so the self-cleansing velocity is maintained.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Sanitary Engineering chapter 3 questions →