Skip to main content

Causes of PT ratio and phase errors

Short answer

Ratio error in a PT stems from voltage drops in winding resistances and leakage reactances due to load and no-load currents, worsening with higher burden. Phase angle error is caused mainly by magnetizing current and reactive voltage drops, with its magnitude dependent on burden power factor.

Discuss the causes of ratio error and phase angle error in PT.

In an ideal PT, V_s = V_p/K_n, exactly in phase opposition. In a practical PT, the voltage drops in the winding impedances and the no-load current cause ratio error and phase angle error.

Phasor relation

 V_p = (reversed) E_p + I_p(R_p + jX_p)
 E_s = V_s + I_s(R_s + jX_s)
 I_p = I₀ + I_s/n   (I₀ = I_m + I_w, n = N_p/N_s)

So the reversed V_s differs from V_p in magnitude (ratio error) and angle (phase error).

Causes of ratio error

  1. No-load (exciting) current I₀ flowing through the primary resistance and leakage reactance produces a voltage drop.
  2. Load current flowing through the primary and secondary resistances (R_p, R_s) and leakage reactances (X_p, X_s) causes further drop.
  3. Burden: a higher burden (more VA) means more current and larger drops, so the ratio error increases.
  4. Burden power factor: at lagging pf the reactive drops add more directly to the magnitude.
  5. A supply voltage or frequency different from rated changes I₀.
 Ratio error (%) = (K_n − R)/R × 100,  R = V_p/V_s

Causes of phase angle error

  1. Magnetising current I_m and loss current I_w flowing through the winding impedance shift the phase of E_p relative to V_p.
  2. Resistive drops (I·R) of the windings, especially at unity-pf burden.
  3. Leakage reactance drops at lagging-pf burden.
  4. Burden magnitude and power factor.

Methods to reduce errors

  • Low flux density and good core material to reduce I₀.
  • Low winding resistance and leakage reactance (thick conductors, interleaved windings).
  • Turns compensation (slightly fewer primary turns).
  • Keeping the burden within rating.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Switchgear and Protection chapter 2 questions →