- 2081 Bhadra · 5 marks
Quantity method for load bearing brick building
Short answer
For load-bearing brick buildings, quantities are taken by either long wall–short wall method (long walls out-to-out = c/c + width; short walls in-to-in = c/c – width; quantity = L×B×D at each level) or centre-line method (total centre length minus half-width per T-junction). The first suits varied wall thicknesses, the second uniform sections.
Write down the general method of taking out quantities in a load bearing brick masonry building with their suitability.
In a load bearing brick masonry building the walls carry the load and the foundation is a continuous strip below them. The quantities of earthwork, PCC, foundation masonry and superstructure are taken out for each wall by one of these methods.
1. Long wall - short wall method
- Choose the walls running in the longer direction as long walls, the others as short walls.
- Length of long wall (out-to-out) = centre-to-centre length + half the foundation (or wall) width at each end, .
- Length of short wall (in-to-in) = centre-to-centre length - half the width at each end, .
- Quantity = length x breadth x depth for each wall at every level (trench, PCC, footing, plinth, wall), because the widths change with depth.
- Suitable for: buildings with several rooms, walls of different thicknesses, and where the foundation has different widths for different walls.
2. Centre line method
- Find the total centre-line length of all walls (main and partition).
- Deduct for the junctions: for each T-junction deduct half of the wall width; a cross-junction counts as two T-junctions, so one full width is deducted.
- Quantity = corrected total length x width x depth of each section.
- Suitable for: buildings having walls of the same section throughout, rectangular rooms, quick estimates. It is not accurate where the sections differ.
Procedure for both
- Mark the walls on the plan with their centre lines.
- Calculate the length of each as per the chosen method.
- Take out earthwork, PCC, masonry up to plinth, DPC, then superstructure masonry.
- Deduct for the openings (doors, windows, ventilators), lintels and beams, to get the net masonry.
In Nepal both methods are accepted; the centre line method is quicker, and the long wall-short wall method is preferred for exactness.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Methods of taking out quantities · Estimating and Costing, chapter 2 · asked 6×
- Load bearing building: excavation, brick, plaster · Estimating and Costing, chapter 6
- Materials for 10 m³ brick masonry 1:3 · Estimating and Costing, chapter 4
- Materials for 115 m³ brick masonry 1:3 · Estimating and Costing, chapter 4
- Brick masonry pier: brickwork and pointing · Estimating and Costing, chapter 6
- Building: brick 1:6, ceiling plaster, PCC · Estimating and Costing, chapter 6
- Earthquake protection of load bearing masonry · Building Technology, chapter 11
- Retrofitting a brick masonry building · Building Technology, chapter 11
- Safe load on a brick masonry column · Design of Timber and Masonry Structures, chapter 5
- Seismic base shear of a masonry building · Design of Timber and Masonry Structures, chapter 7