- 2072 Chaitra · 8 marks
Flexible vs rigid design; Westergaard temperature stresses
Short answer
Flexible pavement uses layered elastic theory, CBR/SN, and protects subgrade; rigid design treats slab as plate on elastic foundation using modulus k and flexural stress. Westergaard’s temperature concept models curling from top-bottom temperature difference, with reduced edge stress σ = CEαΔT/2 depending on slab length/radius ratio.
Differentiate between flexible pavement design and rigid pavement design. Describe Westergaard's concept for temperature stresses.
Flexible pavement design vs rigid pavement design
| Basis | Flexible pavement design | Rigid pavement design |
|---|---|---|
| Structural action | Layered system; load spread through layers | Slab acting in flexure (plate on elastic foundation) |
| Theory used | Burmister layered elastic theory, empirical CBR or AASHO methods | Westergaard, Bradbury, Pickett-Ray analysis |
| Main design variable | Thickness of each layer (SN or total thickness) | Slab thickness and joint details |
| Subgrade parameter | CBR or resilient modulus | Modulus of subgrade reaction |
| Traffic input | Cumulative standard axles (msa, ESAL) | Wheel load, load repetition (fatigue), CVPD class |
| Critical stress/strain | Tensile strain at bottom of bituminous layer; vertical strain on subgrade | Flexural tensile stress at slab edge/corner (load + temperature) |
| Temperature | Affects stiffness of bituminous mix | Causes warping and frictional stresses, so joints are needed |
| Codes | IRC:37, AASHTO-93, Asphalt Institute, Road Note 31 | IRC:58, AASHTO rigid, PCA |
Westergaard's concept of temperature stresses
Westergaard (1927) treated the slab as a plate on a dense-liquid foundation and analysed curling due to a temperature difference between top and bottom.
- A temperature gradient across the thickness makes the top and bottom expand or contract differently, so the slab tends to curve. In the daytime the top is warmer and the slab edges curl down; at night the edges curl up. The slab weight and the subgrade reaction resist the curvature, creating stresses.
- If the slab were completely restrained from curving, the stress would be .
- For a finite slab free to curl, the stress is reduced by coefficients that depend on the ratio of slab length to radius of relative stiffness (). Bradbury's version of Westergaard's result for the edge is
and for the interior .
- For short slabs ( below about 4) is small, so closely spaced joints reduce warping stress; for slabs about 8-9 long reaches a maximum (about 1.08), and then decreases slightly.
- The stress is tension at the bottom in the daytime and tension at the top at night; it is added to the load stress for the critical combination.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Temperature stresses in rigid pavement; dowel bar design · Transportation Engineering II, chapter 2
- Flexible vs rigid; radius of relative stiffness, k · Transportation Engineering II, chapter 2
- Flexible pavement design with 8 CBR values · Transportation Engineering II, chapter 2
- Flexible pavement failures; deflection overlay design · Transportation Engineering II, chapter 4
- Repair vs rehabilitation; rigid pavement failures · Transportation Engineering II, chapter 4
- Pavement design factors; IRC rigid design steps · Transportation Engineering II, chapter 2 · asked 2×
- Flexible versus rigid retaining structures · Foundation Engineering, chapter 5 · asked 3×
- Concept of rigid and deformable bodies · Applied Mechanics, chapter 1
- Concept of particle, rigid and deformable body · Applied Mechanics, chapter 1
- Steel-aluminium bar with temperature rise: stresses · Strength of Materials, chapter 3