Skip to main content

Effect of parameters on conductor and insulator cost

Short answer

Increasing power or line length raises conductor cost per km (larger conductor for current/drop) but does not directly change insulator cost. Raising voltage lowers conductor cost (current decreases) but increases insulator cost (more insulation). More circuits keep total conductor cost about the same while insulator cost grows roughly proportionally to circuit number.

Explain the effect of varying following parameter on conductor and insulator cost per unit length of transmission line. (i) Power to be transmitted and length of line (ii) Voltage level (iii) Number of circuit

Line current is I=P3 Vcos⁡ϕ NcI = \dfrac{P}{\sqrt{3}\,V\cos\phi\,N_c} per circuit. Conductor size depends mainly on current, while insulator size depends only on voltage.

(i) Power to be transmitted and length of line

  • Conductor cost: larger PP means larger current, so a larger conductor area (for thermal limit and to keep losses low); conductor cost per km rises roughly in proportion to PP. Longer LL increases voltage drop and loss, so for long lines a larger conductor (or higher voltage) is needed, again raising conductor cost per km.
  • Insulator cost: per km it does not depend directly on PP or LL, because insulation depends only on voltage. Indirectly, large PP and long LL push the design to a higher voltage, which increases insulator cost per km.

(ii) Voltage level

  • Conductor cost: current ∝1/V\propto 1/V, so conductor area and conductor cost per km fall as voltage rises (loss ∝1/V2\propto 1/V^2 for the same conductor). At EHV, however, minimum size or bundling may be fixed by corona, so the fall stops.
  • Insulator cost: number of discs, string length, cross-arm length, tower height and clearances all increase with voltage; insulator cost per km rises roughly in proportion to VV (or faster at EHV due to switching-surge design).

(iii) Number of circuits

  • Conductor cost: for the same total power, each circuit carries 1/Nc1/N_c of the current, so each conductor is smaller, but there are NcN_c times as many. Total conductor cost per km is roughly the same or a little higher (smaller conductors cost more per unit current), while losses for the same total aluminium are similar.
  • Insulator cost: number of strings is proportional to NcN_c, so insulator cost per km roughly doubles from single to double circuit. Double-circuit towers are taller and heavier, but cheaper than two separate S/C lines.
Parameter increasedConductor cost/kmInsulator cost/km
Power PPIncreasesNo direct change
Length LLIncreases (to limit drop/loss)No direct change
Voltage VVDecreasesIncreases
Number of circuits NcN_cAbout same / slight increaseIncreases (≈ proportional)

These opposite trends give an optimum (most economical) voltage and number of circuits for each PP and LL.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transmission and Distribution System Design chapter 2 questions →