Skip to main content

Number of insulator discs for 220 kV line

Short answer

After applying correction factors (FWR=1.15, NACF=1.1, FOS=1.1) to the required withstands and using the given disc flashover data, lightning requires 14 discs, power-frequency wet requires 14, and switching surge requires 15 discs. The governing number is 15 discs per suspension string (string length about 2.31 m).

Compute the number of insulator discs required for a single circuit, 220 kV, 50 Hz overhead transmission line considering the various external and internal over voltages. Use the related data given in the appendix.

[Given Table A-2: Withstand voltage capability for different system voltages:]

Maximum system voltage (kV)1 minute dry withstand (kV)1 minute wet withstand (kV)Impulse withstand (kV)
123215185450
145265230550
255435395900
4207606801550

[Given Table A-3: Flashover voltages for 254 × 154 mm disc insulators:]

No. of discs1 minute dry FOV (kV)1 minute wet FOV (kV)Impulse FOV (kV)
18050150
215590255
3215130355
4270170440
5325210525
6380250610
7435290695
8485330780
9535370860
10585410945
116354501025
126854851105
137305201185
147755551265
158205901345
168656201425
179106501505
189556801585
1910007101665
2010457401745

[Minimum air clearance: 6.5 inch per 10 kV (rms) and factor of safety = 8 inch.]

Data: 220 kV, single circuit, 50 Hz. From Table A-2 (220 kV class row): maximum system voltage 255 kV, 1-min dry withstand 435 kV, 1-min wet withstand 395 kV, impulse withstand 900 kV. Usual design factors assumed: flashover withstand ratio (FWR) = 1.15, non-atmospheric condition factor (NACF) = 1.1, factor of safety (FOS) = 1.1, so

k=1.15×1.1×1.1=1.3915k = 1.15 \times 1.1 \times 1.1 = 1.3915

1. External over-voltage: lightning

Vreq=900×1.3915=1252.35 kVV_{req} = 900 \times 1.3915 = 1252.35\ \text{kV}

Table A-3 (impulse FOV): 13 discs = 1185 kV < 1252.35; 14 discs = 1265 kV. → 14 discs

2. Internal over-voltage: switching surge

Assume switching surge ratio SSR = 2.8 (usual for 220 kV).

Vss=SSR×2 Vmax3=2.8×2×2553=582.98 kV (peak)Vreq=582.98×1.3915=811.21 kV (peak)=811.21/2=573.62 kV (rms)\begin{aligned} V_{ss} &= SSR \times \frac{\sqrt{2}\,V_{max}}{\sqrt{3}} = 2.8 \times \frac{\sqrt{2} \times 255}{\sqrt{3}} = 582.98\ \text{kV (peak)} \\ V_{req} &= 582.98 \times 1.3915 = 811.21\ \text{kV (peak)} \\ &= 811.21/\sqrt{2} = 573.62\ \text{kV (rms)} \end{aligned}

Compared with 1-min wet FOV: 14 discs = 555 kV < 573.62, 15 discs = 590 kV. → 15 discs

3. Power-frequency over-voltage

Wet: 395×1.3915=549.64395 \times 1.3915 = 549.64 kV → wet FOV 14 discs = 555 kV → 14 discs Dry: 435×1.3915=605.30435 \times 1.3915 = 605.30 kV → dry FOV 11 discs = 635 kV → 11 discs

Result

ConditionRequired (kV)Discs
Lightning impulse1252.3514
Switching surge573.62 (rms eq.)15
Power freq., wet549.6414
Power freq., dry605.3011

The largest requirement governs: 15 discs (254 × 154 mm) per suspension string (switching surge governs). String length ≈15×0.154=2.31\approx 15 \times 0.154 = 2.31 m. (Tension strings commonly use one extra disc.)

(If the IEC value Vmax=245V_{max} = 245 kV were used instead, the switching requirement would be 551.12 kV rms and 14 discs would just suffice.)

Check of air clearance: a=6.5×255/310+8=103.70a = 6.5 \times \frac{255/\sqrt{3}}{10} + 8 = 103.70 in ≈2.63\approx 2.63 m.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transmission and Distribution System Design chapter 3 questions →