Skip to main content

T/F: % power loss equals % energy loss

Short answer

FALSE. Percentage energy loss equals % peak power loss × (LLF/LF), and LLF ≤ LF, so % energy loss is lower. For 0.4 LF, 10% peak power loss yields only 5.8% energy loss.

For a given amount of power to be transmitted over a given distance, state whether the following statement is TRUE or FALSE. Justify your answer with a brief explanation: In practical case, percentage power loss and percentage energy loss in a transmission line is same.

FALSE.

The percentage power loss is measured at peak load, while the percentage energy loss is averaged over time. Because losses vary as the square of the load, they are not equal.

Justification:

%Ploss=Ploss,peakPmax×100%Eloss=Ploss,peak×LLF×TPmax×LF×T×100=%Ploss×LLFLF\begin{aligned} \%P_{loss} &= \frac{P_{loss,peak}}{P_{max}} \times 100 \\ \%E_{loss} &= \frac{P_{loss,peak} \times LLF \times T}{P_{max} \times LF \times T} \times 100 = \%P_{loss} \times \frac{LLF}{LF} \end{aligned}

Since LF2≤LLF≤LFLF^2 \le LLF \le LF, we get LLF/LF≤1LLF/LF \le 1, so % energy loss is less than % peak power loss.

Example: % peak power loss = 10%, LF = 0.4. Using LLF=0.3LF+0.7LF2LLF = 0.3LF + 0.7LF^2:

LLF=0.3(0.4)+0.7(0.16)=0.232%Eloss=10×0.2320.4=5.8%\begin{aligned} LLF &= 0.3(0.4) + 0.7(0.16) = 0.232 \\ \%E_{loss} &= 10 \times \frac{0.232}{0.4} = 5.8\% \end{aligned}

So 10% power loss corresponds to only 5.8% energy loss.

The two are equal only when LF=LLF=1LF = LLF = 1, i.e. a perfectly constant load, which never occurs in practical lines. (If constant losses such as corona or transformer core loss are included, those parts have LLF = 1, but the overall figures still differ.)

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transmission and Distribution System Design chapter 6 questions →