Skip to main content

T/F: sag absent with supports at different heights

Short answer

FALSE. Sag disappears when the span is short or the level difference is large, not small. If the level difference is small, the lowest point remains inside the span and sag exists.

For a given amount of power to be transmitted over a given distance, state whether the following statement is TRUE or FALSE. Justify your answer with a brief explanation: In case of support at different heights, the sag may be absent if either the span length or support level difference is small.

FALSE.

The sag "disappears" when the span is short or when the level difference between supports is large, not small.

For supports at different heights (span LL, level difference hh), the lowest point of the conductor lies at a distance

x1=L2−ThwLx_1 = \frac{L}{2} - \frac{Th}{wL}

from the lower support. When x1≤0x_1 \le 0, the lowest point falls at or beyond the lower support. The conductor then rises all the way from the lower support to the higher one, and there is no sag (dip) within the span. The condition is:

L2≤ThwL  ⇒  h≥wL22T\frac{L}{2} \le \frac{Th}{wL} \;\Rightarrow\; h \ge \frac{wL^2}{2T}

So the sag is absent if:

  • the span L is small (the right-hand side wL2/2TwL^2/2T is small), or
  • the level difference h is large, or
  • the tension is high relative to the conductor weight.

Example: with L=300L = 300 m, w=1.2w = 1.2 kg/m and T=3000T = 3000 kg, wL2/(2T)=18wL^2/(2T) = 18 m. A level difference of 20 m (more than 18 m) gives no dip. A level difference of 5 m gives a normal dip with the vertex inside the span. A small level difference therefore does not remove the sag; a short span or a large difference does.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transmission and Distribution System Design chapter 4 questions →