Skip to main content

Four loads: maximum BM at C

Short answer

Place the 70 kN load at C as the critical load. With the influence line ordinates 2.40, 3.60, 2.80, 1.60 m for the train positions, the maximum bending moment at C is 692.0 kN m.

Find the maximum bending moment at C for the beam and loading as shown in fig-5. [Figure: loads 50 kN, 70 kN, 80 kN, 60 kN with spacings 2 m, 2 m, 3 m moving over a beam AB with A hinge, B roller; AC = 6 m and CB = 9 m (span 15 m).]

Data: simply supported beam ABAB, L=15L = 15 m; CC at a=6a = 6 m from AA, b=9b = 9 m. Loads 50, 70, 80, 60 kN with spacings 2 m, 2 m, 3 m (50 kN at one end). Total W=260W = 260 kN.

ILD for MCM_C

Peak ordinate abL=6×915=3.6\dfrac{ab}{L} = \dfrac{6\times 9}{15} = 3.6 m. Ordinate 0.6x0.6x for x≤6x\le 6 and 0.4 (15−x)0.4\,(15-x) for x≥6x\ge 6.

Critical load

Condition: WL+Pka≥WL≥WLa\dfrac{W_L + P_k}{a} \ge \dfrac{W}{L} \ge \dfrac{W_L}{a}, with WL=26015=17.33\dfrac{W}{L} = \dfrac{260}{15} = 17.33 kN/m.

For the 70 kN load at CC (train moving left to right, 60 kN leading): load on the left without it =50=50 kN, with it =120=120 kN.

1206=20≥17.33≥506=8.33\frac{120}{6} = 20 \ge 17.33 \ge \frac{50}{6} = 8.33

The condition holds, so the 70 kN load must be at CC. Positions from AA: 50 kN at 4 m, 70 kN at 6 m, 80 kN at 8 m, 60 kN at 11 m.

Load (kN)Position (m)Ordinate (m)P x y (kN m)
5042.40120.0
7063.60252.0
8082.80224.0
60111.6096.0
MC,max=692.0 kN mM_{C,max} = 692.0\ \text{kN m}

If the train moves in the opposite direction (50 kN leading), the 80 kN load goes to CC (positions 60 kN at 3 m, 80 kN at 6 m, 70 kN at 8 m, 50 kN at 10 m), and the same calculation gives 692.0 kN m, the same value.

Answer: maximum bending moment at CC = 692.0 kN m.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures I chapter 5 questions →