Skip to main content

Four loads on 60 m girder: BM at C, absolute

Short answer

Maximum bending moment at C is found by placing the 215 kN load at C, yielding 8093.3 kN m. Absolute maximum bending moment is 9121.0 kN m, occurring under the 215 kN load when placed at 29.70 m from A.

Determine maximum bending moment at C and absolute maximum bending moment in the girder shown in figure below when four concentrated loads move from left to right. [Figure: loads 170 kN, 215 kN, 150 kN, 120 kN with spacings 3 m, 2 m, 3 m; girder AB of 60 m; C at 20 m from A.]

Data: girder ABAB, L=60L = 60 m; section CC at a=20a = 20 m from AA, b=40b = 40 m. Loads from the rear: 170, 215, 150, 120 kN at spacings 3 m, 2 m, 3 m; the train moves left to right (120 kN leads, as drawn). Total W=655W = 655 kN.

(i) Maximum BM at C

ILD for MCM_C: peak abL=20×4060=13.33\dfrac{ab}{L} = \dfrac{20\times 40}{60} = 13.33 m; ordinate 2x3\dfrac{2x}{3} for x≤20x\le 20 and 20(60−x)60\dfrac{20(60-x)}{60} for x≥20x\ge 20.

Place the 215 kN load at CC. Load on the left of CC including it: 170+215=385170 + 215 = 385 kN.

38520=19.25>65560=10.9>17020=8.5\frac{385}{20} = 19.25 > \frac{655}{60} = 10.9 > \frac{170}{20} = 8.5

The condition for maximum is satisfied. Positions from AA: 170 kN at 17 m, 215 kN at 20 m (at CC), 150 kN at 22 m, 120 kN at 25 m.

Load (kN)Position (m)Ordinate (m)P x y (kN m)
1701711.3331926.7
2152013.3332866.7
1502212.6671900.0
1202511.6671400.0
MC,max=8093.3 kN mM_{C,max} = 8093.3\ \text{kN m}

(ii) Absolute maximum BM

Distance of the resultant behind the 120 kN load: xˉ=170(8)+215(5)+150(3)655=4.405\bar x = \dfrac{170(8)+215(5)+150(3)}{655} = 4.405 m. Trying each load with the resultant placed symmetrically about mid-span:

Load placed near mid-span (kN)Position of load (m)M under it (kN m)
17028.208682.8
21529.709121.0
15030.709010.4
12032.208435.4

The largest value is under the 215 kN load, at 29.70 m from AA. Then the loads are at: 170 kN: 26.70 m, 215 kN: 29.70 m, 150 kN: 31.70 m, 120 kN: 34.70 m (all on the girder).

RA=324.2 kN,Mmax=RA×29.70−(moments of the loads on its left)=9121.0 kN mR_A = 324.2\ \text{kN}, \qquad M_{max} = R_A\times 29.70 - (\text{moments of the loads on its left}) = 9121.0\ \text{kN m}

Answer: (i) MC=8093.3M_C = 8093.3 kN m; (ii) absolute maximum BM = 9121.0 kN m under the 215 kN load.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures I chapter 5 questions →