Skip to main content

Four loads on 100 m girder: BM at C, absolute

Short answer

Maximum bending moment at C is obtained by placing the 160 kN load at C, giving 12081.0 kN m (or 12171.0 kN m if the train direction is reversed). Absolute maximum bending moment is 13293.9 kN m, occurring under the 180 kN load when placed at 50.84 m from A.

Determine maximum bending moment at section C and also the absolute maximum bending moment when the set of concentrated loads moves from left to right of the girder shown in figure below. [Figure: loads 100 kN, 160 kN, 180 kN, 120 kN with spacings 4 m, 3 m, 2 m; girder AB of 100 m span; section C at 35 m from A.]

Data: girder ABAB, L=100L = 100 m; section CC at a=35a = 35 m from AA, b=65b = 65 m. Wheel loads from the rear: 100, 160, 180, 120 kN at spacings 4 m, 3 m, 2 m; the train moves left to right (assumed as drawn, so the 120 kN load leads). Total W=560W = 560 kN.

(i) Maximum BM at C

ILD for MCM_C: peak abL=35×65100=22.75\dfrac{ab}{L} = \dfrac{35\times 65}{100} = 22.75 m; ordinate 0.65x0.65x for x≤35x\le 35 and 0.35(100−x)0.35(100-x) for x≥35x\ge 35.

Place the 160 kN load at CC. Load on the left of CC including it: 100+160=260100 + 160 = 260 kN.

26035=7.43>560100=5.6>10035=2.86\frac{260}{35} = 7.43 > \frac{560}{100} = 5.6 > \frac{100}{35} = 2.86

The condition for maximum is satisfied. Positions from AA: 100 kN at 31 m, 160 kN at 35 m (at CC), 180 kN at 38 m, 120 kN at 40 m.

Load (kN)Position (m)Ordinate (m)P x y (kN m)
1003120.1502015.0
1603522.7503640.0
1803821.7003906.0
1204021.0002520.0
MC,max=12081.0 kN mM_{C,max} = 12081.0\ \text{kN m}

(If the train moves the other way, with the 100 kN load leading, the same method gives 12171.0 kN m.)

(ii) Absolute maximum BM

Resultant from the 120 kN (leading) load: xˉ=100(9)+160(5)+180(2)560=3.679\bar x = \dfrac{100(9)+160(5)+180(2)}{560} = 3.679 m behind it. For each load, place it and the resultant symmetrically about mid-span and find the moment under the load:

Load at mid-span positionPosition of load (m)M under it (kN m)
100 kN47.3412549.6
160 kN49.3413232.4
180 kN50.8413293.9
120 kN51.8412988.9

The largest is under the 180 kN load. With this load at 50.84 m from AA, the loads are at 100 kN: 43.84 m, 160 kN: 47.84 m, 180 kN: 50.84 m, 120 kN: 52.84 m (all on the girder).

RA=284.7 kN,Mmax=RA×50.84−(moments of the loads on its left)=13293.9 kN mR_A = 284.7\ \text{kN}, \qquad M_{max} = R_A\times 50.84 - (\text{moments of the loads on its left})= 13293.9\ \text{kN m}

Answer: (i) MC=12081.0M_C = 12081.0 kN m; (ii) absolute maximum BM = 13293.9 kN m under the 180 kN load.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures I chapter 5 questions →