Skip to main content

Overturning and sliding check with shear strength

Short answer

With full uplift: overturning FS 1.39, friction FS 0.83, but shear friction factor 7.49 confirms sliding safety. Without uplift FS improves. Provide drainage to reduce uplift.

Check the stability of concrete gravity dam against overturning and sliding. Consider μ = 0.7, γconcrete = 24 kN/m³, average shear strength of material at the horizontal section (q) = 1400 kN/m. [Figure: gravity dam with vertical upstream face and top width 6 m; the downstream face is vertical for the top 13 m and then slopes over a further 20 m height to the toe, giving a base of 6 m + 15 m = 21 m; upstream water depth is 30 m.]

Geometry and assumptions (per metre length)

  • Dam height =13+20=33= 13 + 20 = 33 m; water depth h=30h = 30 m; no tailwater.
  • Top width 6 m; downstream face vertical for 13 m, then slopes 15 m horizontally over 20 m height; base B=21B = 21 m.
  • γw=9.81\gamma_w = 9.81 kN/m³, γc=24\gamma_c = 24 kN/m³, μ = 0.7, shear strength q=1400q = 1400 kN/m² (taken per m² of base).
  • Uplift is taken as full (C = 1), varying from γwh\gamma_w h at heel to zero at toe.
      6 m
    +----+
    |    |  13 m
 30 | W1 +
 m  |     \  W2   20 m
 -> |      \
heel+-------\ toe
    <6>|<-15->
       B = 21 m

Forces and moments about the toe

ForceValue (kN)Arm (m)Moment (kN·m)
W1 = 6×33×244,752 ↓18.0+85,536
W2 = ½×15×20×243,600 ↓10.0+36,000
P = ½×9.81×30²4,414.5 →10.0−44,145
U = ½×9.81×30×213,090.2 ↑14.0−43,262
∑V=4,752+3,600−3,090.2=5,261.9 kN∑MR=121,536,∑MO=44,145+43,262=87,407 kN⋅m\begin{aligned} \sum V &= 4{,}752 + 3{,}600 - 3{,}090.2 = 5{,}261.9\ \text{kN} \\ \sum M_R &= 121{,}536, \quad \sum M_O = 44{,}145 + 43{,}262 = 87{,}407\ \text{kN·m} \end{aligned}

Overturning

FSo=121,53687,407=1.39FS_o = \frac{121{,}536}{87{,}407} = 1.39

Sliding

FSs=μ∑V∑H=0.7×5,261.94,414.5=0.83SFF=μ∑V+Bq∑H=3,683.3+21×14004,414.5=7.49\begin{aligned} FS_s &= \frac{\mu\sum V}{\sum H} = \frac{0.7 \times 5{,}261.9}{4{,}414.5} = 0.83 \\ SFF &= \frac{\mu\sum V + Bq}{\sum H} = \frac{3{,}683.3 + 21 \times 1400}{4{,}414.5} = 7.49 \end{aligned}

Results

CheckWith upliftWithout upliftRequired
FS overturning1.392.75≥ 1.5
FS sliding (friction)0.831.32≥ 1.0
Shear friction factor7.497.98≥ 3–5

(Without uplift: ∑V=8,352\sum V = 8{,}352 kN, ∑MO=44,145\sum M_O = 44{,}145 kN·m.)

Answer: With full uplift, FS overturning = 1.39 (slightly below 1.5) and friction FS = 0.83, but the shear friction factor = 7.49 > 5, so the dam is safe against sliding when the shear strength of the joint is counted. Without uplift, FS overturning = 2.75 and SFF = 7.98 (safe). To improve overturning safety, drainage holes should be provided to reduce uplift.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Hydro Power chapter 4 questions →