Skip to main content

Sag and tension in easiest condition

Short answer

Using the change-of-state equation from the toughest condition (tension 4000 kg, resultant weight 2.171 kg/m) to the easiest (60 °C, no wind), the tension is solved as 1728 kg. Maximum vertical sag = 0.844×300²/(8×1728) = 5.49 m.

Evaluate the maximum sag and tension in easiest condition for a transmission line of span 300 m with following data: Conductor: cross-section: 226 mm²; Diameter: 20 mm; Weight: 0.844 kg/m; UTS: 8000 kg.

ParameterToughest conditionEasiest condition
Temperature0°C60°C
Wind pressure100 kg/m²0
TensionUTS/2?
Ice thickness00

The tension in the easiest condition is found from the change-of-state (stringing) equation, starting from the toughest condition. The maximum (vertical) sag then follows.

Assumed (not given): E=0.789×106E = 0.789\times10^6 kg/cm² and α=17.73×10−6\alpha = 17.73\times10^{-6} /°C, the usual values for ACSR.

Toughest condition (1): 0°C, wind 100 kg/m²

T1=UTS/2=8000/2=4000 kgww=p d=100×0.020=2.0 kg/mW1=0.8442+2.02=2.171 kg/m\begin{aligned} T_1 &= \text{UTS}/2 = 8000/2 = 4000\ \text{kg}\\ w_w &= p\,d = 100\times0.020 = 2.0\ \text{kg/m}\\ W_1 &= \sqrt{0.844^2 + 2.0^2} = 2.171\ \text{kg/m} \end{aligned}

Easiest condition (2): 60°C, no wind

W2=0.844W_2 = 0.844 kg/m, θ2−θ1=60∘\theta_2 - \theta_1 = 60^\circC, and

AE=2.26 cm2×0.789×106=1.7831×106 kgAE = 2.26\ \text{cm}^2\times0.789\times10^6 = 1.7831\times10^6\ \text{kg}

Stringing equation T22(T2+K2)=K1T_2^2(T_2 + K_2) = K_1

K2=−T1+αΔθ AE+W12L2AE24T12=−4000+17.73×10−6×60×1.7831×106+2.1712×3002×1.7831×10624×40002=−4000+1896.9+1969.4=−133.7 kgK1=W22L2AE24=0.8442×3002×1.7831×10624=4.7632×109\begin{aligned} K_2 &= -T_1 + \alpha\Delta\theta\,AE + \frac{W_1^2L^2AE}{24T_1^2}\\ &= -4000 + 17.73\times10^{-6}\times60\times1.7831\times10^6 + \frac{2.171^2\times300^2\times1.7831\times10^6}{24\times4000^2}\\ &= -4000 + 1896.9 + 1969.4 = -133.7\ \text{kg}\\ K_1 &= \frac{W_2^2L^2AE}{24} = \frac{0.844^2\times300^2\times1.7831\times10^6}{24} = 4.7632\times10^9 \end{aligned}

Solve T22(T2−133.7)=4.7632×109T_2^2(T_2 - 133.7) = 4.7632\times10^9:

T2T_2 (kg)LHS
17004.527×1094.527\times10^9
17504.950×1094.950\times10^9
1728.34.763×1094.763\times10^9 ✓
T2=1728 kgT_2 = 1728\ \text{kg}

Maximum sag (easiest condition)

Dmax=W2L28T2=0.844×30028×1728.3=5.49 mD_{max} = \frac{W_2L^2}{8T_2} = \frac{0.844\times300^2}{8\times1728.3} = 5.49\ \text{m}

For comparison, the sag in the toughest condition is 2.171×3002/(8×4000)=6.112.171\times300^2/(8\times4000) = 6.11 m. That sag is inclined, at tan⁡−1(2.0/0.844)=67∘\tan^{-1}(2.0/0.844) = 67^\circ, so its vertical component is only 6.11×0.844/2.171=2.376.11\times0.844/2.171 = 2.37 m. The easiest condition therefore gives the largest vertical sag.

Answer: in the easiest condition the tension is about 1728 kg (21.6% of UTS) and the maximum vertical sag is about 5.49 m.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transmission and Distribution System Design chapter 4 questions →