Skip to main content

Capacitor size, four-node 11 kV feeder

Short answer

Optimum capacitor size equals the resistance-weighted average of reactive flows in the sections it relieves. Sum of R_i Q_i = 1866.92, sum of R_i = 8, so Q_c = 233.4 kVAR for maximum loss reduction.

For the 11 kV primary distribution network shown below, determine the size (kVAR) of the capacitor to be placed at the location shown in diagram to achieve the maximum loss reduction. For simplifying the analysis assume voltage at each node is 1 p.u. All impedances are in p.u. at 1000 kVA.

[Figure: radial feeder from a 1000 kVA, 33/11 kV source substation S to node A through 1+j2, A to B through 2+j3, B to C through 2+j4, C to D through 3+j4. Loads through distribution transformers: 100 kVA at 0.6 p.f. lag at A, 100 kVA at 0.8 p.f. lag at B, 150 kVA at 0.9 p.f. lag at C, 200 kVA at 0.6 p.f. lag at D. The capacitor is placed at node D.]

Method (optimum single capacitor)

With all node voltages taken as 1 p.u., the reactive current in a section equals its reactive power flow QiQ_i (p.u.). A shunt capacitor QcQ_c at the end node reduces the reactive flow in every section between the source and that node from QiQ_i to (Qi−Qc)(Q_i - Q_c). The loss reduction is

ΔPL=∑iRi[Qi2−(Qi−Qc)2]=∑iRi(2QiQc−Qc2)\begin{aligned} \Delta P_L &= \sum_i R_i\left[Q_i^2-(Q_i-Q_c)^2\right] = \sum_i R_i\left(2Q_iQ_c-Q_c^2\right) \end{aligned}

For maximum loss reduction, d(ΔPL)dQc=∑iRi(2Qi−2Qc)=0\dfrac{d(\Delta P_L)}{dQ_c} = \sum_i R_i(2Q_i-2Q_c)=0, so

Qc,opt=∑iRiQi∑iRiQ_{c,opt} = \frac{\sum_i R_iQ_i}{\sum_i R_i}

i.e. the optimum capacitor equals the resistance-weighted average of the reactive flows in the sections it relieves. The ratio does not depend on whether RR is in ohms or p.u., so kVAR can be used directly.

 S-(1+j2)-A-(2+j3)-B-(2+j4)-C-(3+j4)-D
          |        |        |        |
       100kVA   100kVA   150kVA   200kVA
       0.6 lag  0.8 lag  0.9 lag  0.6 lag [Qc]

Reactive load at each node

NodeS (kVA)p.f.sin⁡ϕ\sin\phiQ (kVAR)
A1000.60.880.00
B1000.80.660.00
C1500.90.435965.38
D2000.60.8160.00

Reactive flow in each section

SectionR (p.u.)Q flow (kVAR)R × Q
S–A1365.38365.38
A–B2285.38570.77
B–C2225.38450.77
C–D3160.00480.00
Total81866.92

(Section flows: S–A carries all four loads, A–B carries B+C+D, and so on.)

Optimum capacitor

Qc=∑RiQi∑Ri=365.38+570.77+450.77+4801+2+2+3=1866.928=233.4 kVARQ_c = \frac{\sum R_iQ_i}{\sum R_i} = \frac{365.38+570.77+450.77+480}{1+2+2+3} = \frac{1866.92}{8} = 233.4\ \text{kVAR}

In p.u. on 1000 kVA, Qc=0.233Q_c = 0.233 p.u. Only the resistances matter for loss; the reactances affect voltage drop, not I2RI^2R loss.

Answer: Capacitor at node D ≈ 233 kVAR for maximum loss reduction (nearest standard bank ≈ 240–250 kVAR).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transmission and Distribution System Design chapter 7 questions →